SAUL’S REPLACEMENT ENTERS THE STORY
DAVID ENTERS THE SERVICE OF THE MAN GOD WILL REPLACE
As we enter into the second half of the account of the beginning of the reign of the kings over Israel, we read stories that have parallels to those of Homer, from the same time frame. Pagan commentators often refer to these as “legends” and dismiss most of the stories of David and Saul as later “mythic history” that are told here to bolster the position of the house of David over the other claimants.
Just because a story has similar elements to one from a similar age does not mean both are consigned to the category of “legend” or “myth”. Homer’s stories are becoming more accepted as based upon real historical events and a growing array of evidence backs this. The fact that we have in the behaviour of the Philistines many parallels to the heroes of the Homeric stories would ring true for this period, as the Philistine’s origins are in the Aegean area and they enter Palestine around the time of the real fall of Troy, which has been discovered to be most likely just as Homer described it.
The story of Goliath of Gath, and the champion fighting for the entire army, is one we are all familiar with from these early proto-Greek stories. I accept the rest of this book named first Samuel as real history, written close to the time of the events, not later myth, and I see no reason to doubt anything written here. It is a wonderful account of some remarkable, and yet also very human men and women. We have the sadness of Samuel, the tragedy of Saul and his sons, and the victory of David, who is as flawed as each of us, and the men he replaced. It is a story of God’s grace and mercy!
This is no myth written to elevate David to sainthood, for we meet the real man here; we see his strengths and his weaknesses. This balanced view is unlike all other stories of kings from the ancient world, for most omitted anything that was negative. The writer here tells all, for this man David stands in the power of God alone, and has victory because God is with him. This is biblical history giving the spiritual viewpoint, and so it covers the sins and evils of men and tells us how good men recover and foolish ones destroy themselves. It is not a moral tale/fable, but real and powerful history.
As David enters the scene, Saul’s power and majesty starts to seriously decline as the quality of his decision making deteriorates. Since the great victory over the Philistine army described in chapter fourteen only a few years pass before David is anointed by the dying Samuel, and then he enters the palace of Saul for a time as the harpist for the king’s madness. The actual time frame of the rest of the book is uncertain.
David may be around fourteen when he first appears and would appear to be still under twenty when he slays Goliath and enters the king’s service as a soldier. He will be thirty when he becomes king himself on the death of Saul upon Mt Gilboa. His path to the crown is roughly the same time frame as that of Joseph to becoming second ruler of Egypt, the Lord taking around sixteen years to train his men in the furnace of affliction before they are given power to wield safely.
The rest of this book contains the account of this path to kingship and in it we will see many examples of God’s great grace towards David, in teaching him and in preserving him. We also see God’s amazing grace towards Saul, for this man could have received blessing and dying grace but he had chosen the path of desperate self-centeredness, and his tragedy runs its inevitable course. Personality Disorders left to run their course can only produce tragic outcomes.
God works upon those who would lead His people and brings them to the place of dependence upon Him, or they are replaced. Saul never learns to fully trust the Lord and obey His will and so he leaves the pages of history. David learns to love the Lord with all his heart through these years and learns to trust God through the deep despair at times that he must walk through. We see his weakness revealed here regarding both anger and sexual lust, but we see his character emerge as one of the greatest men of history. David gives hope for us all – for if this man can be lifted up, then we all can be. Psalm 103:10-18, 1 Peter 5:5-10.

