Great Mentors of Faith · The Life of Moses · Lesson 11 of 19

Chapter 21, part 1

About 23 min read

Text size
🎧 Listen to the lectures for this course (19)

All the lectures for this course

Dr John McEwan's recorded lectures. Tap Listen, then press play. You can keep reading while it plays.

These recordings cover all 8 parts of this study together.

  1. The Life of Moses 1
  2. The Life of Moses 2
  3. The Life of Moses 3
  4. The Life of Moses 4
  5. The Life of Moses 5
  6. The Life of Moses 6
  7. The Life of Moses 7
  8. The Life of Moses 8
  9. The Life of Moses 9
  10. The Life of Moses 10
  11. The Life of Moses 11
  12. The Life of Moses 12
  13. The Life of Moses 13
  14. The Life of Moses 14
  15. The Life of Moses 15
  16. The Life of Moses 16
  17. The Life of Moses 17
  18. The Life of Moses 18
  19. The Life of Moses 19

INTRODUCTION

These judgments (mishpatim) are the rights of the people within the Law. The rights of masters and slaves are dealt with, and the rights of parents, children, and the innocent party’s rights in the matter of any unlawful slaying. Deuteronomy 25 – 29 expands upon this section. Principles of Law are laid down here and are still embodied in our laws today. In this chapter we see that the unborn child is treated as if it is a full member of society and any killing of a child in the womb was to be treated as a homicide.

Rules for those sold into slavery set limits on the years they could serve, and special rules were laid down for the treatment of girls sold as servants-wives to ensure they were not sexually used and then cast aside. In the matter of homicide, the rules laid down here make the intention to kill a key point that separates accidental from culpable deaths. This is the foundation for modern law and sets this code well apart from those of the other nations that were filled with many injustices and arbitrary nonsense. Do not let any liberal nonsense peddler say that Hammurabi was the source of Moses words here, for Moses revelation from God is light years ahead of anything else. Others learn from Israel!

EXODUS 21:1-17

“21:1 Now these are the judgments which thou shalt set before them. 2 If thou buy an Hebrew servant, six years he shall serve: and in the seventh he shall go out free for nothing. 3 If he came in by himself, he shall go out by himself: if he were married, then his wife shall go out with him. 4 If his master have given him a wife, and she have born him sons or daughters; the wife and her children shall be her master's, and he shall go out by himself. 5 And if the servant shall plainly say, I love my master, my wife, and my children; I will not go out free: 6 Then his master shall bring him unto the judges; he shall also bring him to the door, or unto the door post; and his master shall bore his ear through with an aul; and he shall serve him for ever. 7 And if a man sell his daughter to be a maidservant, she shall not go out as the menservants do. 8 If she please not her master, who hath betrothed her to himself, then shall he let her be redeemed: to sell her unto a strange nation he shall have no power, seeing he hath dealt deceitfully with her. 9 And if he have betrothed her unto his son, he shall deal with her after the manner of daughters. 10 If he take him another wife; her food, her raiment, and her duty of marriage, shall he not diminish. 11 And if he do not these three unto her, then shall she go out free without money. 12 He that smiteth a man, so that he die, shall be surely put to death. 13 And if a man lie not in wait, but God deliver him into his hand; then I will appoint thee a place whither he shall flee. 14 But if a man come presumptuously upon his neighbour, to slay him with guile; thou shalt take him from mine altar, that he may die. 15 And he that smiteth his father, or his mother, shall be surely put to death. 16 And he that stealeth a man, and selleth him, or if he be found in his hand, he shall surely be put to death. 17 And he that curseth his father, or his mother, shall surely be put to death.”

REFLECTION

Verses 1- 2

. The concept of slavery to us is abhorrent and our reaction to this evil may cloud our understanding of these verses, so we need to put aside the comparison of American and British slavery and see here a totally different thing. The slaves of the old Roman and British Empire had no rights and abuse was common, whereas in Israel slavery, or indentured service as it was, was covered by these rights/responsibilities for both the slave and the master. The servant had been sold to the master, and as we will see later in this book and the others, in the Mosaic period, the reason was normally non-payment of debts.

There was no such thing as bankruptcy in the ancient world as there is in our own. In that day you could not have your debts wiped by a court and then head away and fraudulently start up a new business. You had to pay your debts off by working for the people you owed money, for nothing, or be sold as a slave to pay the debt, and if your debts were significant, your entire family could be sold to pay the debt. The person who loaned money in good faith was always to be repaid in full.

In our day the people who loan money have no such assurances, and normally end up receiving little, with the person who borrowed the money heading away to start up again, often with his money secured in a family trust or an overseas bank account. A debt was not a casual thing in Moses’ day as it is in our own! Our business world has been ruined by the casual attitude of many towards their debts and businesses and nations have been brought to their knees as a result. The World Financial Crisis (WFC) 2007 – 2014 has been the result of casual attitudes towards indebtedness, and continuing financial instability is being caused by this on-going national/international sin/evil. Satan’s policies rule now and it is too late; we are on the path to the Tribulation period and the evils of the debt-economy will be used to control all.

While initially this indentured service (Fixed term slavery) appears awful, stop and consider the alternative in this day. Without land (sold already to pay the debt) all the indebted man could do was work as a labourer, and there may not be any such work locally, and if the debt was owed after sale of land, the man owed the money wouldn’t want the debtor wandering off to another place to work, with a “fake promise” to pay later, such as in our modern day we have to hear! The Law’s first concern was that the person who was owed money was paid back, and that all in society knew that to borrow was a serious thing, and a debt was indeed a debt of honour, and would be paid in money or sweat, but never in blood or jail.

Once land and buildings were sold, the family of the man who owed money had no-where to live and if there was no work, was unable to feed his family. The concept of Israelite slavery stepped in here to ensure all were protected. The man who lost the money could offer himself as a slave for hire to pay the debt, and if he and his wife or family were sold, it had to be as a “job lot” (whole family group – with only the man working if he alone was sold – the wife was expected to keep doing the household chores for the family – but could be put to work if the debt was so high that her labour also was required to pay it off, as could older children to make full repayment) but the entire family was to be kept together.

The Hebrew slave was sold for the value of seven years labour, and the money was paid immediately to the man he had borrowed money from and not repaid. The man who was now a slave, went to work for his new master (who had paid his debt) and worked for seven years to repay him the value of his purchase price, plus living expenses. At that point he was set free again, and any people he brought into the household were set free with him.

If he wanted to remain a slave/servant in the household, he was able to do this with a special ceremony(below). This was at times recognized by people, that they could not look after themselves and slavery was preferred to starvation. He was sold for seven years only, not for life; it was a limited term “slavery” (best called “indentured service”) and not like the American and British evils that later flourished in the 17th and 18th centuries until abolished by the Christian parliamentarians in the UK, and by war in the USA. Families were to be kept together in the process.

In effect this was a form of social welfare for the poor who had been reduced to circumstances where they were not able to care for themselves. It was meant to be humane but just to the person owed money, and the slave and their family were under the same law as other Israelites, to be protected from abuse and murder, and entitled to one day off per week to worship, and able to take full part in all worship. They were to be fed and clothed at the expense of the master who had purchased their labour for seven years.

They were sent away at the end of seven years without any additional money, unless it was “earned”, but well fed and clothed, and no last minute “expenses” were to be charged which would mean they could not go free. The Lord covered all possibilities to ensure his people were protected, even those who were foolish with money, or had bad luck with a business venture. Deuteronomy 15:11.

Verses 3 – 4

. The family that came in with the man were to leave with the man. No charges were to be made or deducted for his family’s “room and lodging”, for the family’s labour was to be taken as sufficient payment for everything that was spent by the family while he/they were in service. The second statement of the Law regarding this in Deuteronomy 15:1-15, makes it clear that the person was not to be sent away without goods to ensure he and his family were fed while they re-established themselves. Read Deuteronomy 15:12-15 especially.

If, while he was with the master, the master gave him a wife, then she was expected to stay, unless she herself was emancipated at the same time, and if they had children, the children were the master’s responsibility to care for and they stayed. This opens up the next issue, which was the recognition by the man who had been sold, that he was not able to look after his own affairs and would be better off living within a greater household. Such a man could accept a wife, and with it the recognition that he would be staying in the household forever. To accept a wife as a slave, was to accept a lifetime of slavery, and for some that was true “social welfare” as they couldn't support themselves in freedom.

The alternative was to wait for the seven years to be over and then take a wife as a free man. Those without the self control and ability to think ahead would be selecting lifetime slavery, and for such people that status in Hebrew society was probably the best place for them. In the Roman and Greek worlds slavery remained a terrible evil until it was abolished by the Christian emperors, but in Hebrew society it was a place where those who didn’t want, or couldn’t look after their own affairs, were then cared and provided for.

Verses 5 – 6

. The man who had been caught by economic or climatic catastrophe, or had been careless financially, and had ended up a seven-year bonded man, could at the time for his emancipation make a decision to stay forever in his master’s house. This was to be a formal and fully informed legal decision. It was a recognition, that for many, what they wanted in life was the safety and security of stable living arrangements, new clothes, and plenty of food, and that was all they wanted. Their freedom didn’t matter to them, for they were able to enjoy the Sabbath rest weekly, attend worship with the family, and had all they needed in food and clothing.

These people were the “welfare beneficiaries” of their day and the family that cared for them had to provide all they needed. Such a man would be literally “nailed” to the door of the house and by having his ear pierced he accepted lifetime service to his master and his household. Leviticus 25:23-31, 39-44, Deuteronomy 15:16-18. This recognition of lifetime bonded service was to be certified by the local Judges so that a legal process was involved, and there was oversight of it to ensure that there was no abuse, and that all understood their rights and responsibilities in the process.

This process was meant to be a humane way to deal with poverty, but it was abused by evil men as all good processes can be. In Nehemiah’s day the rulers of the people were capitalistic during a famine period and great distress was caused, and great anger was kindled in Nehemiah. Even the judges had been corrupted in their practises in Nehemiah’s day. God’s purpose in these laws was to protect people who were not able or prepared to look after themselves, not open the door for others to abuse them. Nehemiah 5:1-13. Even if these people who became slaves were lazy, foolish, and didn't value their freedom or personal responsibility to care for their families, they were still to be cared for humanely. Welfare beneficiaries were not to be despised and abused, even if their life-style choice was beneath God’s call.

Verses 7 – 11

. The situation in Nehemiah’s day had really got out of hand, with the daughters of the starving people sold into indentured service, at times to protect careless parents. Sadly, the whole catastrophe had been caused by the manipulation of economic conditions by the wealthy, using high interest rates for poorer and often unthinking borrowers to bankrupt them and seize their land. Such things have happened many times in history, and for God’s people they were not to occur, for under the Mosaic Law, interest rates were not to be charged for any loan.

The way loans were to be made was by way of an agreed flat fee, and/or a agreed share of the crop planted only once it came in, or a specific percentage share in the profit of a venture, once it came to it’s successful end. To be a loaner of money was therefore a harder and riskier thing than in our day of set interest rates, and this is why, if a person defaulted on the loan, they had to pay by indentured service, and there had to be certainty for the loaner that they would be paid back by labour or by cash.

The price of throwing a wedding in biblical times was extensive. Gifts had to be given to relatives of the groom, and although a “bride price” might be paid, it would not be enough to throw a party for all the guests that would be expected to be invited. To feed several hundred people for three to seven days was significant. John 3:1-10. For a family which was low of funds there were two options; the first was to accept that no marriage would be allowed for their girl, or they had to “sell” her into service in a greater house and hope she found favour with a wealthy member of the household, who would then marry her at the cost of the new household.

The parents were “selling” their rights to decide who their daughter married, and she was accepting that she had to work as a servant in that household until her seven years were up, or she was redeemed by an interested man. He in effect paid the bride price and any monies her service had not worked out at that point, but the cost of the wedding would be paid by the family that had bought her from her parents. She was like Ruth waiting for her Boaz to come as her redeemer, who would pay the price to set her free.

For a poor girl this was not “slavery” but “service”, and it was opportunity to escape her parent’s poverty and enter a wealthy home where she may make a good match with a more successful man than her parents might have known. It also meant the parents were able to pay their bills! It was also a great risk, for, without the Mosaic Law protection, she may have been bought by a man who simply wanted a girl for his mistress and would then sexually abuse her until he got sick of her and then could cast her out at the seven-year point and replace her with another. Specific rules are laid out here to protect the girls thus sold, so that they had the best opportunity to make the good marriage that they needed for protection and advancement in their agrarian society.

Read these verses carefully. The maidservant was to be treated differently than the indentured male servant, and she was to be granted more protection, for she was more vulnerable sexually to abusiveness. She was purchased as a servant for seven years also, but the prospect was of marriage to a family/household member, and if anyone acted deceitfully or abusively with her in this process, she was to be set free without any money being paid to release her.

As a student of ancient history for many years now I am still struck as I read these verses by how different this law was to that of the Romans, Greeks and other so called “Civilized” nations. They treated all girls as commodities and if the master wanted to take sexual advantage of them he did, and none raised their voice to criticize. The girl could be raped and abused and then sold to others or placed by the master straight into the local brothels. All of this evil was forbidden under the Mosaic system and the Judges/Levites were to oversee this and ensure that injustice and evil did not occur. They failed to follow this at times, but the Lord’s will for this people was clearly laid out here.

In verse eight, if the master had betrothed himself to the girl, to take her as his wife, then he had to follow that promise through and marry her, and her children were ranked equally with any other wife who was not a servant. This was the pattern established by the Patriarchs, although not fully followed by Jacob, who played favourites. Genesis 30. If for any reason he falls out of love with her, then he was not to enslave her permanently, nor sell her to any foreign buyer, but he had to allow her to be redeemed by another. He was not able to lock her away, as was the custom with many cultures in the Middle East, to ensure that no other man ever had access to that woman. He had to allow her to be redeemed by another, or send her away free himself, without any payments, back to her father’s home, with no disgrace upon her.

If he had betrothed her to his son, then he had to deal with her as a daughter, and that meant he was to have no sexual activity with her at all, and that he was expected to pay for the wedding, as if she was his own daughter. If he took another wife and she was more favoured than this servant girl, then he was to treat her as his wife still, feed, clothe and care for her all her days, and she was not to be treated as a servant again. If any man, having married a woman, fell out of love with her, then he was not excused the duty of care towards her. This care for servant girls, and protection from sexual exploitation, was to extend to captives from warfare also. Deuteronomy 21:11-17.

Verses 12 – 17

. These verses cover the rules on manslaughter, and define what is, “accidental homicide”, and what is murder. Murder was always to be followed by the death penalty, but accidental death, where there as no intention to kill, was to be treated differently. The principle of guilt was to be established by the judges, and they had to discover clear evidence of intention, or the person was not guilty of murder. The word used for “smite” here is a word that means to deliberately inflict fatal wounds. If there is no evidence of intention to warn or defend by disabling then its murder. The clear intention is seen by the nature of the wounds, and to kill when such action is not justified is murder. Genesis 9:5-6, Leviticus 24:17, Numbers 35:16-34, Deuteronomy 19:11-13.

To cover the cases where a man would find it difficult to prove his innocence, and argue self defence safely, after the rage of the dead man’s relatives had fallen a little, the man who believed himself guilty of accidental homicide, or self defence, could flee to nominated cities of refuge, where he would await a fair and impartial trial before the judges there, rather than the local judges where the death occurred. Numbers 35:1-15, Deuteronomy 19:1-10.

This concept of a place of refuge to await a fair trial is raised in Exodus 21:13, but the cities are only nominated in Numbers and Deuteronomy, for those books were written as they neared the land and the particular cities are identified, but this is the introduction of the concept. Now note the phrase, “God shall deliver him into his hand”. What does this mean? Does it mean God delivers him to death? It covers what we would say was a death that would not have been expected given the circumstances and the blows struck. Under our own law it is covered in what is known as the, “eggshell skull principle”.

We deviate from the Law of Moses, and we hold a person guilty if they strike a blow and the person struck dies, even if others would not have died as a result of a similar blow. The fact that a person has a weakness, or you hit a “lucky spot” and they die is the striker’s problem under our present law, and the striker will be guilty of homicide, although not probably of murder. The Mosaic Law was more lenient in this matter, identifying that if a person dies as a result of something that for others would be an irritation, then it is to be looked upon as “an act of God”, and they are not guilty of murder, and are not to be executed, but they are to flee to a city of refuge, and wait there until their case is heard and the evidence gathered to support this form of defence.

In verse fourteen the religious defence is denied any murderer. They cannot later “cling to the altar” and claim religious forgiveness, or later conversion as their defence or a mitigating factor. 1 Kings 1:50-53, 2:25-34. There was to be no pleas in mitigation for murder, other than self defence or accidental death. This principle was highlighted in America a few years ago, when a female murderer converted in jail to Christianity and her supporters argued she should be spared the death penalty for the murders, because she was now “no threat” to anyone, and would be a productive member of society now. She was executed, and according to this biblical principle, she was rightly executed, for she dies, not for her state now, but her state when she took other’s lives without any cause, other than lust for money and sheer pleasure in her power to kill. Having said this, we would argue for clemency, that she might serve in jail (below).

Now I am personally glad that we do not have summary execution in all countries, for we have many men and women saved in jail, who otherwise would be executed as unbelievers. We have a number of EBCWA Learning Centres operating in jails around the world and many prisoners are the teachers in them, and many of these men WERE murderers and are now ministers of the Gospel of Life. As new creations they serve the risen Lord and bring hope and life where previously they brought death and disaster. They stand with Paul, who was also a murderer! Remember his actions and his words, for he was a multiple murderer, and it is his life that is our hope, and the reason the attitude of the church changed towards the death penalty. Acts 8:1-3, 1 Corinthians 6:9-11, 1 Timothy 1:12-15.

While murder was punishable by death, so was simply striking a father or mother. To violate the sacred duty to parents was to be worthy of death. To have bitterness, hatred, resentment, or malice towards parents who were not guilty of any abusive action (in itself guilty of death), was to place oneself under the ultimate penalty. A person who does not honour their parent but strikes them as if they were a dog to be disciplined, by that act they show that they have contempt for the institutions of God, and so they are a danger to all men and women in their society. Before they have the chance to show contempt to others in society and destroy other’s lives, they were to be executed on proof of their assault upon their parents. Once again, the word for “strike” is a severe blow leaving wounds or bruises that indicate great malice, contempt and hatred. Moses goes further than these introductory principles in Deuteronomy 21:18-23, 27:24-25.

Slave trading in any other way, than with voluntary seven-year service as an indentured servant, or sale of captives through war, was to be seen as the “theft of a man’s life” and was to be punishable by death. In the ancient world generally, a stranger wandering alone could be seized and sold, and none would raise any problem with it, nor would there be any penalty for the slave seller later. Things were to be different in Israel, and all were to be secure from theft of their goods, or their lives. The rule here covered the three people who could stop the evil practise of man stealing; the man who seized the stranger, the man who sold him and the man who had him working for him, and all three were to be executed.

This was a severe system, but it meant that, when it was applied that a person could walk secure in the knowledge that it was unlikely that a slave trader would seize them, for such people were in fear of the consequences. It is a reminder to us in our liberal and weak world, that consequences that are sure and consistent do have an impact on the evil, for they calculate their risks carefully when crime is their business. Fear is a wonderful teacher! We face a choice in society; either the criminals are in fear, or the population is in fear! God’s way selects the criminal to fear, modern liberalism selects the general population!

Text size

Course text © Evangelical Bible College of Western Australia, shared with their permission. Bible quotations are mostly from the King James Version, as in the original. Back to all courses