Great Mentors of Faith · The Life of Samuel the Judge and Saul the King · Lesson 15 of 17

Chapter 14, part 1

About 24 min read

Text size
🎧 Listen to the lectures for this course (13)

All the lectures for this course

Dr John McEwan's recorded lectures. Tap Listen, then press play. You can keep reading while it plays.

These recordings cover all 2 parts of this study together.

  1. The Life of Samuel the Judge and Saul the King 1
  2. The Life of Samuel the Judge and Saul the King 2
  3. The Life of Samuel the Judge and Saul the King 3
  4. The Life of Samuel the Judge and Saul the King 4
  5. The Life of Samuel the Judge and Saul the King 5
  6. The Life of Samuel the Judge and Saul the King 6
  7. The Life of Samuel the Judge and Saul the King 7
  8. The Life of Samuel the Judge and Saul the King 8
  9. The Life of Samuel the Judge and Saul the King 9
  10. The Life of Samuel the Judge and Saul the King 10
  11. The Life of Samuel the Judge and Saul the King 11
  12. The Life of Samuel the Judge and Saul the King 12
  13. The Life of Samuel the Judge and Saul the King 13

INTRODUCTION

One of the biggest dangers when we have failed the Lord in some way is that we emotionally react to our failure, and in recovery phase, act on the basis of our emotion rather than the basis of Bible doctrine and Holy Spirit controlled reason. The first indication of Saul’s emotional instability comes to light in this chapter. If my estimation of the timing of the events recorded here is correct, it may also help to psychologically explain why Saul goes overboard in this first great test since the Ammonite invasion at his anointing.

He has been waiting for action for twenty years, accepting Philistine domination and all that this meant, and has had to keep a low profile in the land. He has been the “invisible king” for twenty years. He may even have been accused by some of being a coward or traitor with the Philistines. He has failed to deliver his people from their enemies, but he has enabled them to build economic prosperity and build their population numbers back up. He has plenty of men to call on to be soldiers, but they are under-equipped when compared to their enemies, and they do not at this point have the mental attitude of soldiers. When he sent Israel to its tents after the Ammonite campaign, he probably expected them to take their captured weapons and train daily with them, ready for the eventual call up to fight the Philistines.

Saul is searching for a dramatic and powerful victory to re-assert his kingship and have the people follow him in power to destroy their enemies. He has waited for nearly twenty years, and during that time the men have either stopped or been erratic in their training, and even ceased to feel and behave as soldiers, and the morale of all has dropped to zero.

Saul is desperate for action that will provide the opportunity to rebuild morale and establish the kingdom in power. The problem with desperation is that we operate on what we describe as “hunches”, and all they are is emotional feelings; they are not the leading of the Holy Spirit. When we operate in emotional enthusiasm we operate outside the filling of the Holy Spirit, for He works in accordance with God’s Plan, not our enthusiasm or emotional feelings. Saul starts to unravel at the very time he is asked to act dynamically for God. He will have great victory here and again later in his reign, but the seeds are sown and seen here of the madness that will grow and unhinge him later.

When the chance came to attack the Philistines he seized it, and this appears to have been done without consultation and direction from Samuel and the Lord. He is in a situation that he expected would lead to dramatic victory, but it has led to a dramatic test of faith. His second desperate act is another one that betrays his spirit of fear and desperation. He failed to wait for Samuel, offered sacrifices in violation of the Mosaic Law, and he has been told he will lose the kingdom eventually as a result of this. Psychologically this plays on his mind, for he now knows he cannot hold the kingdom forever, and that he will not pass it on to his sons.

He then appears to repent of these errors of judgment, and he follows up the rebuke of Samuel by obediently following him back to Gibeah. So far, so good! At that point he appears to be operating in faith and prepares to launch his attack upon the vastly superior enemy. He launches the main attack only when he has clear words from God regarding this being the right time to attack.

He then sadly does a third really dumb thing! He takes a solemn oath that anyone who eats before the last enemy are dead is cursed and is to be executed. This was unnecessary and burdensome, and narcissistic, but it was a solemn oath, and according to the Mosaic Law, it was binding. Casual oaths were not to be taken, but once taken, they were to be fulfilled. Numbers 30, Deuteronomy 23:21-23, Judges 11:30-40. God did not want His servants uttering hasty vows and oaths; they were not to be emotional in their faith but reasonable, prayerful, and thoughtful.

As we enter this chapter, we enter the time of “reaping” for Saul’s decision to launch his premature assault upon the Philistines. Luke 14:25-32. This is the turning point for Saul in his life and work. Let us see the heart and mind of this truly great man as he faces the psychological pressures of the unfolding consequences of his failure to consult Samuel after twenty years of waiting for action. Before you judge this man too harshly, pause and reflect upon the possible state of your own mental stability after enduring twenty years of oppression by a foreign power, and yet having received the Word of God that made you king and deliverer for your people.

He has no right to expect God to “bail him out” of this, any more than we have any right to think this way when we over-step the plan, but God, in His mighty grace and power, will deliver the Israelites, and do so through Saul. Saul himself will be blessed and will have stability in his home, morality in his marriage, and yet he will mentally unravel, for he finds it too hard to accept that he is to be replaced by another, and that his sons will not sit upon the throne.

He has faced the test of Gideon and initially failed, but he will recover from that and see many victories. His last great test is that of John the Baptist; he must accept his replacement. John 3:30. He will fail to do this and persecute his replacement, David, but he will still be used of the Lord for another twenty years. We have much to learn about the GRACE of God, and also His DIVINE DISCIPLINE.

1 SAMUEL 14:1-26

14:1 Now it came to pass upon a day, that Jonathan the son of Saul said unto the young man that bare his armour, Come, and let us go over to the Philistines' garrison, that is on the other side. But he told not his father. 2 And Saul tarried in the uttermost part of Gibeah under a pomegranate tree which is in Migron: and the people that were with him were about six hundred men; 3 And Ahiah, the son of Ahitub, Ichabod's brother, the son of Phinehas, the son of Eli, the LORD's priest in Shiloh, wearing an ephod. And the people knew not that Jonathan was gone. 4 And between the passages, by which Jonathan sought to go over unto the Philistines' garrison, there was a sharp rock on the one side, and a sharp rock on the other side: and the name of the one was Bozez, and the name of the other Seneh. 5 The forefront of the one was situate northward over against Michmash, and the other southward over against Gibeah. 6 And Jonathan said to the young man that bare his armour, Come, and let us go over unto the garrison of these uncircumcised: it may be that the LORD will work for us: for there is no restraint to the LORD to save by many or by few. 7 And his armourbearer said unto him, Do all that is in thine heart: turn thee; behold, I am with thee according to thy heart. 8 Then said Jonathan, Behold, we will pass over unto these men, and we will discover ourselves unto them. 9 If they say thus unto us, Tarry until we come to you; then we will stand still in our place, and will not go up unto them. 10 But if they say thus, Come up unto us; then we will go up: for the LORD hath delivered them into our hand: and this shall be a sign unto us. 11 And both of them discovered themselves unto the garrison of the Philistines: and the Philistines said, Behold, the Hebrews come forth out of the holes where they had hid themselves. 12 And the men of the garrison answered Jonathan and his armour bearer, and said, Come up to us, and we will shew you a thing. And Jonathan said unto his armour bearer, Come up after me: for the LORD hath delivered them into the hand of Israel. 13 And Jonathan climbed up upon his hands and upon his feet, and his Armour bearer after him: and they fell before Jonathan; and his armour bearer slew after him. 14 And that first slaughter, which Jonathan and his armour bearer made, was about twenty men, within as it were an half acre of land, which a yoke of oxen might plough. 15 And there was trembling in the host, in the field, and among all the people: the garrison, and the spoilers, they also trembled, and the earth quaked: so it was a very great trembling. 16 And the watchmen of Saul in Gibeah of Benjamin looked; and, behold, the multitude melted away, and they went on beating down one another. 17 Then said Saul unto the people that were with him, Number now, and see who is gone from us. And when they had numbered, behold, Jonathan and his armour bearer were not there. 18 And Saul said unto Ahiah, Bring hither the ark of God. For the ark of God was at that time with the children of Israel. 19 And it came to pass, while Saul talked unto the priest, that the noise that was in the host of the Philistines went on and increased: and Saul said unto the priest, Withdraw thine hand. 20 And Saul and all the people that were with him assembled themselves, and they came to the battle: and, behold, every man's sword was against his fellow, and there was a very great discomfiture. 21 Moreover the Hebrews that were with the Philistines before that time, which went up with them into the camp from the country round about, even they also turned to be with the Israelites that were with Saul and Jonathan. 22 Likewise all the men of Israel which had hid themselves in mount Ephraim, when they heard that the Philistines fled, even they also followed hard after them in the battle. 23 So the LORD saved Israel that day: and the battle passed over unto Bethaven. 24 And the men of Israel were distressed that day: for Saul had adjured the people, saying, Cursed be the man that eateth any food until evening, that I may be avenged on mine enemies. So none of the people tasted any food. 25 And all they of the land came to a wood; and there was honey upon the ground. 26 And when the people were come into the wood, behold, the honey dropped; but no man put his hand to his mouth: for the people feared the oath.

REFLECTIONS

Verses 1 – 3.

Impulsiveness is a character trait of this family, but Jonathan is a man of God and is thinking as a soldier. The need for reconnaissance and spying on the enemy is paramount in warfare and Saul is not thinking as a general here, for he is too scared to move against such a formidable army with such a small army. He has forgotten Gideon and his 300 men. Judges 6-7.

Jonathan realises the most important factor in building morale is to keep an “offensive mentality”, and by moving forward to spy out the enemy’s camp he is acting in a way to build his strength and confidence. He is also preparing for victory by gathering information and seeking opportunities to defeat the enemy. While we wait for orders, as we have seen above, we are to wait actively, and by prayer and Bible study to be pressing on any open doors to see what the Lord wants us to do and be ever ready to do it.

The writer records exactly where Saul was camped, and it was as far away from the Philistines as he can be and still be in the general area of Gibeah. This reference to a pomegranate tree at Rimon tells us that it was still there as the writer records this, and that tells us that the story is recorded probably within a hundred years of the action described here, as the tree does not live hundreds of years. Judges 20:45.

He is there with 600 men, and most importantly he has the key survivor of the priesthood with him now. The main man present is now named. The high priest at the time is Ahiah, who is descended of Ahitub, the son of Phinehas, and the great-grand-son of Eli. 1 Samuel 4:19-22. This High Priest is described as “the Lord’s priest in Shiloh”, which tells us that he is still living in the area, and that he could have been called earlier to offer sacrifices at the camp in Gilgal. 1 Samuel 13:7-14. Shiloh is only a few miles from Gilgal; a round trip of less than a day. The earlier reference to the hiding of the ark indicates that regular sacrifice there has been stopped at Shiloh for a number of years now, but the priests are still active. 1 Samuel 7:1-2. We are reminded Saul hasn't used them as he should have…

Verses 4 – 5.

The exact place Jonathan crossed over from Gibeah towards the enemy camp at Michmash is described in minute detail. Once again, we have the evidence of an eyewitness being spoken to early on and his story recorded, and this can only be the armour bearer. The two great rocks that they climb between to reach the camp are called by name, Bozez, and Seneh. Bozez means the “shining one”, and indicates it shone in the light due to the nature of the quartz rock within it. Seneh means “a craggy rock”, indicating its sharp and rough appearance. Various biblical travellers have believed they have identified these two rocky hills.

It was a difficult climb between these two hills of solid rock and the Philistines clearly do not expect anyone to achieve this climb and so are all but unguarded on that side of their camp, believing the rocky hills are their walls of defence. Over confidence is always the sign of satanic theology and it is nearly always fatal to those who trust in man’s power rather than walk with God.

Verses 6 - 10.

This section of the story tells us that Jonathan has been prayerful in all he does this day. Why did he not tell his father that he was going to do this? Later events show that Saul was very timid and would not have approved any advanced armed reconnaissance and certainly not any trial of arms against the Philistines. Jonathan is taking a terrible risk here, for if he loses the skirmish, then the enemy have the crown prince as their captive, or they have his head on a stake, and the morale of Israel will hit rock bottom. He is taking the right “risk” here however, because he is doing things prayerfully.

Notice the way Jonathan describes the plan to the armour bearer and notice this younger man’s answer. This answer here indicates to me that he is the source of this story, and the writer has either spoken to him or one who heard this story from him. Jonathan’s statement in verse six is the comment that sums up Jonathan’s faith in the character and power of God. He understands what his father does not understand; God does not need large armies to gain victory, He simply needs obedient men who trust in God rather than their numbers or human assets.

One obedient man with the power of the Lord is a majority in every battle. Deuteronomy 32:30, Judges 7:2-7, 2 Chronicles 14:11, Psalms 115:1-9, Jeremiah 9:23-24, Zechariah 4:6. Read each of these great verses, for they are the promises to claim throughout history, and they will be the source of strength for all the armies that will resist the evils of the Great Tribulation period.

The armour bearer is a lot younger than Jonathan, possibly only a lad of fourteen. His job was not to fight, but to carry additional weaponry and pass them to Jonathan when needed, much like a golf caddy! This young man however speaks like a warrior, and he is ready to stand with Jonathan in any situation Jonathan believes is right, and he is ready to fight with Jonathan till the end. This is evidence of inspirational leadership on Jonathan’s part. God’s leaders call their people to “follow” them. Leadership means putting yourself in harm/danger’s way and inviting all who trust the Lord to join you on the battlefield of the Lord’s choosing. Philippians 3:13-17.

Jonathan is thinking as Gideon does, providing two options for the Lord to answer their challenge to the Philistine guards of the camp. In Jonathan’s eyes these men are just evil “uncircumcised” pagans and are already judged by God. He doesn’t see them as great warriors, just weak pagans. Jonathan sees things God's way rather than man's way. If the Philistines show over-confidence and invite the two men over to engage them in combat, then they will take this as an invitation from God to go and slay these men. Jonathan seeks God’s way alone and seeks the Lord’s glory alone. In this manner he prayerfully places himself in the most powerful place for the Lord to bless his endeavours.

Verses 11 – 15.

The two men are still well down the hill from the watch post of the Philistine army on the top of the hills. The Philistines are not alert to danger from their direction and the two men have to openly discover themselves to be seen by their enemies. They probably have to yell aloud to these pagans, who then get up, get dressed in their armour and address them. It is a reminder that the ancient/Homeric rules of warfare apply and are being applied.

Their first words are words of mockery and indicate that they believe that all the Israelites are good at is hiding in holes in the ground. They have all the arrogance that indicates they will not be ready to face a real warrior like Jonathan. They play with the two young men they see below them, inviting them to “show them something” if they come up to them. This is the signal for Jonathan that the Lord has indeed delivered them into his hands. He climbs up the steep slope, having to throw their shields over their backs to climb up on their hands and feet. They are vulnerable at this point and any smart soldier at the top would have dropped a large rock on such attackers, but the Philistines are over-confident!

The second mistake the Philistines make is to allow Jonathan and his armour bearer to reach the area at the top of the hill where there is a flat area, perfect for open fighting, about half an acre in area (about 2000 square metres). Jonathan attacks the small garrison and kills all twenty of them, cutting them to the ground with single blows, which his young armour bearer follows up with a fatal thrust in each case. By working together and wounding then killing these men the entire garrison is dead before they all realise what is happening to them and can call for reinforcements. There is a very public display of this victory in some way we are not told of here.

The enemy quickly hear of the defeat of their men. It may be that they saw the action from their camp below and watched in horror as one after another of their heavily armoured “champion” men falls before this single Israelite and his boy helper. Remember also Jonathan is using captured Philistine weapons and armour, and at this distance do the enemy think one of their own has betrayed the garrison and murdered them, and are their traitors amongst them in the main camp? Terror grips all their forces as they see this, and then the Lord sets His seal upon Jonathan’s action by sending an earthquake at exactly this moment. To these pagan peoples the shaking of the earth spoke of the coming fall of a kingdom, and they all believed that, given what they have just witnessed, it must be their own kingdom that is to fall. To the believers in the camp of Israel the earthquake is simply God demonstrating His awesome power.

Verses 16 – 21.

Saul has set his guards to watch the Philistine’s movements, and they quickly report that there is panic in the Philistine camp after the earthquake, and they see that some action or other is being fought upon the high hill overlooking the enemy camp. They see that the Philistines have also started to kill one another in their blind panic and also their possible fear that Jonathan is from one of their own cities, and it is turning on the others. Saul quickly ascertains who it is on that hill. Only Jonathan and his armour bearer are missing from the army muster. It’s too far away to see clearly, and there are no telescopes at this time!

Saul quickly then calls the High Priest forward and asks for the ark to be brought so that the High Priest might give him the orders to attack or stand still. Saul is nervous now of any action at all, but a good fault here. The ark has been in hiding for over twenty years, but it is back amongst the people here. Saul is nervous of joining the error of the sons of Eli in losing the ark in an ill-judged battle. 1 Samuel 4:5-11. Saul knows the ark is not a good luck charm and that the Philistines will not believe its presence will protect the Israelis today any more than it did years before. Saul seeks the Lord’s words and asks for specific orders that he might lead the army in a godly manner. So far so good!

As Saul is inquiring of the High Priest the noise coming from the Philistine camp has grown to a sound of total chaos and disorder. At this vital point the priest has not brought an answer, and rather than waiting any longer, Saul gives the order to the priest to “withdraw his hands”; that is, he says in effect, “stop praying, I have the answer from the sounds I hear”. He is convinced that the Lord has given them the victory, and he now calls his men to be ready to attack. In this case he is correct, but to start and pray and not wait for the answer to come clearly is simply another indication of Saul’s instability and emotionality.

When they arrive at the scene of the noisy chaos, they see that every Philistine is fighting his neighbour and a great slaughter is going on. The pagans are so busy in the slaughter of each other that they do not notice the Israelite’s small army arrive, but the Israelites who were there with the enemy as their servants now join the Israelites. Now we are not told specifically here, but as later David served as a mercenary for the Philistines, so the Israelites mentioned here may also have been mercenary soldiers serving with the Philistines, ready to fight their own people. At this point however, whatever their previous position, they join their brethren and fight and kill the common enemy.

Verses 22 – 26.

As the noise of the battle intensifies and the news of what is happening spreads, all the Israelites who had hidden themselves within the mountains of Ephraim now re-emerge and join in the slaughter of the enemy. All the local Israelite men are turned from cowards to heroes as they have felt the earthquake and then see their enemy in chaos, and they grab any implement capable of killing a man with, and head for the battlefield. Once they have killed their first Philistine or come across their first body, they will have the armour and the weapons they will need to fight further. God will provide them with good weapons, just as He did the Israelites in the desert under Moses, Exodus 14:27ff.

The writer is quick to identify that it was the Lord who saved Israel that day, not the greatness of Saul or Jonathan, for the earthquake turned the skirmish of Jonathan into a sign from heaven, and the Lord brought the confusion into the camp of the enemy so that they killed each other. The battle surged back and forth, but soon it was flowing in only one direction, towards the coast. The slaughter went from the area around Michmash right until Bethaven.

It is only when the account of the victory is given that the writer records the last act of foolishness of Saul in ordering no-one to eat until the last Philistine was dead. To take a quick meal as you fight keeps you moving forward with energy and 100% concentration. It is standard military practise to provide “action Messing”; that is, meals at all times possible for men in the field so that they can keep actively moving forward. Saul’s order means the men are exhausted and unable to aggressively pursue their enemy through their debilitating thirst and hunger. A great opportunity is missed to totally destroy their enemy. It was an unnecessary order, big on dramatic statement, but dangerously useless to obey!

This enemy army will rebuild and will be the one that eventually kills Saul. His sin here will surely find him out! Numbers 32:23. Notice Saul’s words as they are recorded in verse 24. He speaks as if he seeks “revenge” upon the Philistines, and this gives us the next clue to his character and his role as king through these last twenty silent years. He has clearly been humiliated by the Philistine overlords, year after long year until this point, and now all his anger and desire to revenge himself upon them bursts out in this rash oath. This is another example of the sort of self centred, even narcissistic, and emotional thinking that is Saul’s nature. Such self-centred motivations are unworthy of a great commander.

Leadership calls for calm and cool reasoning under the worst pressures. It certainly calls for extreme caution wherever you feel strongly about a person or group lest you make the wrong decision for personal reasons rather than the proper religious or political ones. Whatever Saul feels is irrelevant to the battle; his job here before the Lord is to wipe this army out to the last man and ensure the country is free of them, not work out any revenge fantasy he has upon them.

The writer now records the story that involves Jonathan once again. The army comes upon a wooded area and a wild beehive has fallen from a tree and burst open on the ground. Honey is the right thing to take in such a situation, as it quickly enters the blood stream as available sugar and gives energy to tired muscles to push on further. No-one touches the honey though through fear of the breaking of the oath of Saul.

The army has respect for their commander, even when he has made a foolish oath, and this tells us that he now has their total allegiance again as a people. Saul is respected and his words are feared. This man has built a reputation, even though he has been under Philistine domination for twenty years. It tells us that he has been a man of great strength and still is a mighty man of valour in his people’s eyes. His deep psychological weakness is however just about to be revealed. This man has a Shakespearean Tragic Flaw, and it is pride and self-centredness.

Text size

Course text © Evangelical Bible College of Western Australia, shared with their permission. Bible quotations are mostly from the King James Version, as in the original. Back to all courses