MATTHEW 27:11-14
11 And Jesus stood before the governor: and the governor asked him, saying, Art thou the King of the Jews? And Jesus said unto him, Thou sayest. 12 And when he was accused of the chief priests and elders, he answered nothing. 13 Then said Pilate unto him, Hearest thou not how many things they witness against thee? 14 And he answered him to never a word; insomuch that the governor marvelled greatly.
KEY WORDS
| Stood | Histemi | Stand [Aorist Passive Indicative] |
| Before | Emprosthen | Before the face of |
| Governor | Hegemon | Governor, Ruler, Procurator |
| Asked | Eperotao | Ask [Aorist Active Indicative] |
| Saying | Lego | Say [Present Active Participle] |
| Art | Eimi | Keep on being [Present Active Indicative] |
| King | Basileus | King |
| Said | Phemi | Affirm [Aorist Active Indicative] |
| Sayest | Lego | Say [Present Active Indicative] |
| Accused | Kategoreo | Accuse [Present Passive Infinitive] |
| Chief Priests | Archiereus | High Priest |
| Elders | Presbuteros | Elders |
| Answered | Apokrinomai | Answer [Aorist Middle Indicative] |
| Nothing | Oudeis | Nothing |
| Said | Lego | Say [Present Active Indicative] |
| Hearest | Akouo | Hear [Present Active Indicative] |
| How many things | Posos | Many things |
| Witness | Katamatureo | Witness against [Present Active Indicative] |
| Answered | Apokrinomai | Answer [Aorist Passive Indicative] |
| Never | Oude | None, Not so much as |
| Word | Rhema | Word |
| Insomuch | Hoste | Insomuch, Such that |
| Marvelled | Thaumazo | Marvel, Wonder [Present Active Infinitive] |
| Greatly | Lian | Greatly, Much |
PERFECT TENSE VERBS – None found
OLD TESTAMENT PROPHECY FULFILLED AT THE FIRST COMING OF THE LORD JESUS CHRIST
| ITEM | OLD TESTAMENT | DESCRIPTION | FULFILMENT |
| 155 | Psalm 38:12-13 | Silent before His accusers | Matthew 27:12-14 |
| Isaiah 53:7b | Silent before His accusers | Matthew 27:12-14 |
REFLECTION
Verse 11. And Jesus stood before the governor: and the governor asked him, saying, Art thou the King of the Jews? And Jesus said unto him, Thou sayest. 12 And when he was accused of the chief priests and elders, he answered nothing. 13 Then said Pilate unto him, Hearest thou not how many things they witness against thee? 14 And he answered him to never a word; insomuch that the governor marvelled greatly.
This is the fourth trial, with Jesus in front of Pontius Pilate, who is called the governor. The word governor should be Procurator, who was the head of government in a third-class province, which Judah was at the time of Christ. The higher-class provinces were those who were under the direct rule of the Emperor and those under the control of the Senate.
Judea is under the over-all jurisdiction of the Senatorial Province of Syria, and Pilate is responsible to that Governor, who has placed Pilate under a “last warning”, due to his excessive violence against Samaritans and Jews in the past.
Pilate was appointed by Tiberius in 26AD as a reward for exceptional military service. He was a Roman knight, or aristocrat, and was initially stationed in Caesarea, which was about 60 kilometres from Jerusalem. After his initial arrival, as a show of strength, (“tough guy arrives!” message) he moved the army headquarters from there to Jerusalem, bringing with them the pagan Roman gods on their standards and shields. These shields were hung on the walls of Jerusalem and caused a riot among the religious Jews who would not tolerate pagan symbols.
Pilate kills large numbers of Jews as a result. This was the start, and he carried on with a satanic arrogance that has run its course by this date – he is on his last warning from the Senate and the Emperor! He is therefore vulnerable to Sanhedrin pressure to do what they want, or they will report him again….
Herod the Great, who was an Idumean Arab, but religious Jew, did not have his likeness put on coins out of deference to the Jews but the Romans had the Emperor’s likeness and Roman gods on theirs. The Jews wrote to Tiberius Caesar about this outrage, and as a result Pontius Pilate arranged for plain clothes soldiers to go and kill a number of Jews. Tiberius then wrote to Pontius Pilate telling him to shape up, as this behaviour was in danger of causing a rebellion, so he went back to base himself mainly in Caesarea, only going up to Jerusalem at major Feasts to ensure “law and order”….
He then commandeered money from the Jewish temple treasury and used it for building an aqueduct to Jerusalem, bringing water from a spring some 60 kilometres away. This again caused problems, even though it was for a public benefit, and he was addressed again by Tiberius for upsetting the Jews. Pilate would always wear his dress uniform, and look down his nose at the Jews, and they did not appreciate that. He was therefore in a delicate political position when the Sanhedrin brought Jesus before him.
There was therefore antagonism between them all, and it cost the Jews a lot to come to Pilate to solve their problem, but they had him under pressure due to their complaints about him so they were confident he would do what they told him to do to save his skin. They all swallowed their pride to get rid of Jesus, someone they both despised.
In spite of the fact, it was very early in the morning Pilate is fully and very formally dressed and ready to conduct this trial. The reason is because earlier that night, Judas, in fulfilment of the second reason that he was needed, came before Pilate and presented the official charge by which the Roman cohort could be released for the arrest. Since Pilate had earlier released the Roman cohort to Judas according to the plan, Judas should now have been there for the trial itself before Pilate.
Pilate is ready for it, Jesus the accused is there but Judas the accuser is not, as he has committed suicide. They therefore have no witness, so they attempt to force Pilate to pass a sentence apart from a witness and apart from any accusation. Great frustration reigns in this illegal façade “show trial”. Not a problem for Hitler or Stalin, but it was for Pilate!
As they are without a prosecuting witness the accusation against Jesus from the religious leaders is that of sedition or conspiring against Rome. They claim that he is going to be a competitor to Caesar, as the King of the Jews. Jesus however says that His kingdom is not of this world, indicating that He is no rival to Caesar.
It is also important to note that the Roman government had taken away the power of the Sanhedrin to execute people prior to this time. The Bible clearly says that He would die on wood, implying that He would be crucified. If however, the Sanhedrin had the power of execution, the Lord Jesus Christ would have been a stoned to death. Therefore, the Roman withdrawal of the authority to execute people was again a critical part of the Plan of God.
MARK 15:2-5
2 And Pilate asked him, Art thou the King of the Jews? And he answering said unto them, Thou sayest it. 3 And the chief priests accused him of many things: but he answered nothing. 4 And Pilate asked him again, saying, Answerest thou nothing? behold how many things they witness against thee. 5 But Jesus yet answered nothing; so that Pilate marvelled.
KEY WORDS
| Asked | Eperotao | Ask [Aorist Active Indicative] |
| Art | Eimi | Keep on being [Present Active Indicative] |
| King | Basileus | King |
| Answering | Apokrinomai | Answer [Aorist Passive Participle] |
| Said | Epo | Say [Present Active Indicative] |
| Sayest | Lego | Say [Present Active Indicative] |
| Chief Priests | Archiereus | High Priest |
| Accused | Kategoreo | Accuse [Imperfect Active Indicative] |
| Many things | Polus | Many things |
| Answered | Apokrinomai | Answer |
| Nothing | Oudeis | Nothing |
| Asked | Eperotao | Ask [Imperfect Active Indicative] |
| Again | Palin | Again |
| Saying | Lego | Say [Present Active Participle] |
| Answerest | Apokrinomai | Answer [Present Middle Indicative] |
| Behold | Idou | Behold, Lo |
| Witness against | Katamatureo | Witness against [Present Active Indicative] |
| 5 | ||
| Answered | Apokrinomai | Answer [Aorist Passive Indicative] |
| Marvelled | Thaumazo | Marvel, Wonder [Present Active Infinitive] |
PERFECT TENSE VERBS – None found
OLD TESTAMENT PROPHECY FULFILLED IN THE GOSPELS AT THE FIRST ADVENT - None found
REFLECTION
Verse 2. And Pilate asked him, Art thou the King of the Jews? And he answering said unto them, Thou sayest it. 3 And the chief priests accused him of many things: but he answered nothing. 4 And Pilate asked him again, saying, Answerest thou nothing? behold how many things they witness against thee. 5 But Jesus yet answered nothing; so that Pilate marvelled.
Up to this time Jesus had been on trial before the Jewish religious leaders on the charge of blasphemy. Now he was taken before the civil court on a charge of treason.
The civil trial took place in three stages, first before Pilate, then before Herod, and finally before Pilate again.
Pilate asked the Lord Jesus Christ if he was the King of the Jews. If he were, and claimed that title without Senate approval, then he was presumably dedicated to the overthrow of Caesar, and thus guilty of treason. That’s all Pilate needed to act. He knew the Sanhedrin this time wouldn’t complain. The chief priests poured out many charges against Jesus. This is seen in the imperfect tense of the word Kategoreo, which means they kept on accusing Him.
Pilate could not get over Jesus’ poise in the face of such overwhelming accusations. He asked why He didn’t defend Himself, but Jesus refused to answer His critics.
Jewish accounts of martyrs, which come down to us from this time, testify frequently to the gentile judges’ astonishment that martyrs refused to cooperate. The Romans hated those who disobeyed them, but did respect courage and poise.
Roman Law did not however interpret silence as an admission of guilt, and so once again Jesus has to help the prosecution to obtain the guilty verdict, but as we will see Pilate knows this is all a charade and totally unjust. He doesn't like Jews, he despises the leadership, but even he is softening towards Jesus – but not enough to bow before Him – and that error is fatal for Pilate for the rest of his life and after his death.
LUKE 23:1-5
1 And the whole multitude of them arose, and led him unto Pilate. 2 And they began to accuse him, saying, We found this fellow perverting the nation, and forbidding to give tribute to Caesar, saying that he himself is Christ a King. 3 And Pilate asked him, saying, Art thou the King of the Jews? And he answered him and said, Thou sayest it. 4 Then said Pilate to the chief priests and to the people, I find no fault in this man. 5 And they were the more fierce, saying, He stirreth up the people, teaching throughout all Jewry, beginning from Galilee to this place.
KEY WORDS
| Whole | Hapas | All |
| Multitude | Plethos | Throng, Multitude |
| Arose | Anistemi | Arise [Aorist Active Participle] |
| Led | Ago | Lead [Aorist Active Indicative] |
| Began | Archomai | Begin [Aorist Middle Indicative] |
| Accuse | Kategoreo | Accuse [Present Active Infinitive] |
| Saying | Lego | Say [Present Active Participle] |
| Found | Heurisko | Find [Aorist Active Indicative] |
| Fellow | - | Not found in the original |
| Perverting | Diastrepho | Corrupt, Pervert [Present Active Participle] |
| Nation | Ethnos | Nation |
| Forbidding | Koluo | Forbid [Present Active Participle] |
| Give | Didomi | Give [Present Active Infinitive] |
| Tribute | Phoros | Tribute |
| Saying | Lego | Say [Present Active Participle] |
| Is | Eimi | Keep on being [Present Active Infinitive] |
| Christ | Christos | Christ, Messiah |
| King | Basileus | King |
| Asked | Eperotao | Ask [Aorist Active Indicative] |
| Saying | Lego | Say [Present Active Participle] |
| Art | Eimi | Keep on being [Present Active Indicative] |
| Answered | Apokrinomai | Answer [Aorist Passive Participle] |
| Said | Phemi | Affirm [Aorist Active Indicative] |
| Sayest | Lego | Say [Present Active Indicative] |
| Said | Epo | Say [Aorist Active Indicative] |
| Chief Priests | Archiereus | Chief Priest |
| People | Ochlos | Multitude |
| Find | Heurisko | Find [Present Active Indicative] |
| No fault | Aition | Crime, Fault |
| Man | Anthropos | Man |
| Were more fierce | Epischuo | More insistent [Imperfect Active Indicative] |
| Saying | Lego | Say [Present Active Participle] |
| Stirreth up | Anaseio | Stir up, Excite [Present Active Indicative] |
| Teaching | Didasko | Teaching [Present Active Participle] |
| All | Holos | All, Whole from which we get holistic |
| Beginning | Archomai | Begin [Aorist Middle Participle] |
| Place | Hode | Here |
PERFECT TENSE VERBS – None found
OLD TESTAMENT PROPHECY FULFILLED IN THE GOSPELS AT THE FIRST ADVENT - None found
REFLECTION
Verse 1. And the whole multitude of them arose, and led him unto Pilate.
The Sanhedrin showed their keenness to rid themselves of the Lord Jesus Christ in the fact that the majority of the Sanhedrin arose and headed off to Pilate to enforce a civil trial.
There were two buildings which the Romans had taken for accommodation in Jerusalem, one was the fortress of Antonia, and the other the magnificent palace of Herod, at the north-western corner of the upper city. The balance of probability is in favour of the second location.
From the slope of the eastern angle opposite the Temple Mount where the palace of Caiaphas was located this procession wound its way up the narrow streets of the upper city to the entrance of the grand palace of Herod the Great, now occupied by the Roman forces.
It is recorded that those who had brought Him, would not themselves enter the palace, because that would make them defiled, and they wouldn’t be able to eat the Passover as they would be unclean until evening. What sheer hypocrisy we see here, where they are plotting the murder of the Lord of glory, killing the one the Passover spoke of and looked forward to, and yet they are concerned about being a ritually unclean for their family Passover meal, which speaks of Him.
Verse 2. And they began to accuse him, saying, We found this fellow perverting the nation, and forbidding to give tribute to Caesar, saying that he himself is Christ a King. 3 And Pilate asked him, saying, Art thou the King of the Jews? And he answered him and said, Thou sayest it. 4 Then said Pilate to the chief priests and to the people, I find no fault in this man. 5 And they were the more fierce, saying, He stirreth up the people, teaching throughout all Jewry, beginning from Galilee to this place.
On arriving before Pilate, who was the Procurator of Judea, the Jewish authorities charged Him falsely. They said he opposed paying taxes to Caesar. Jesus however had said just the opposite, as recorded in Luke 20:25. “And he said unto them, Render therefore unto Caesar the things which be Caesar's, and unto God the things which be God's”. They also said he claims to be Christ the King, and this was worded in such a way as to sound as if Jesus was a revolutionary.
Pilate enquired of Him, saying, “Are you the King of the Jews?”, to which Jesus replied in effect, “You are saying with them, that I am”. Jesus was the legitimate King of the Jews as an inspection of the Temple records at that time would have shown and as confirmed in His genealogy in Matthew chapter 1 and Luke chapter 3. Pilate isn’t miss-led by the false charges, and after examination says he found no fault in the Lord Jesus Christ. This statement was not what the religious leaders wanted to hear, and it resulted in an increase in accusations and pressure put upon Pilate. They said that that He was stirring up the people and as a teacher was promoting insurrection.
It is of note that this was not the first time that Galilee had featured in problems with Rome, as a Galilean had led the tax revolt against the ruling power in AD 6. Jews from Jerusalem tended to view Galileans as inferior to themselves, and a centre for trouble, although much of Galilee was urban and in touch with local Mediterranean culture, just as Jerusalem was.
JOHN 18:28-38
John 18:28 Then led they Jesus from Caiaphas unto the hall of judgment: and it was early; and they themselves went not into the judgment hall, lest they should be defiled; but that they might eat the passover. 29 Pilate then went out unto them, and said, What accusation bring ye against this man? 30 They answered and said unto him, If he were not a malefactor, we would not have delivered him up unto thee. 31 Then said Pilate unto them, Take ye him, and judge him according to your law. The Jews therefore said unto him, It is not lawful for us to put any man to death: 32 That the saying of Jesus might be fulfilled, which he spake, signifying what death he should die. 33 Then Pilate entered into the judgment hall again, and called Jesus, and said unto him, Art thou the King of the Jews? 34 Jesus answered him, Sayest thou this thing of thyself, or did others tell it thee of me? 35 Pilate answered, Am I a Jew? Thine own nation and the chief priests have delivered thee unto me: what hast thou done? 36 Jesus answered, My kingdom is not of this world: if my kingdom were of this world, then would my servants fight, that I should not be delivered to the Jews: but now is my kingdom not from hence. 37 Pilate therefore said unto him, Art thou a king then? Jesus answered, Thou sayest that I am a king. To this end was I born, and for this cause came I into the world, that I should bear witness unto the truth. Every one that is of the truth heareth my voice. 38 Pilate saith unto him, What is truth? And when he had said this, he went out again unto the Jews, and saith unto them, I find in him no fault at all.
KEY WORDS
| Led | Ago | Lead [Present Active Indicative] |
| From | Apo | From the ultimate source |
| Hall of Judgment | Praitorion | Praetorium, Hall of Judgment |
| Was | Eimi | Keep on being [Imperfect Active Indicative] |
| Early | Proia | Early morning |
| Went | Eiserchomai | Go [Aorist Active Indicative] |
| Lest | Hina Me | In order that not |
| Should be defiled | Miaino | Defiled, Contaminated [Aorist Passive Subjunctive] |
| Might eat | Phago | Eat [Aorist Active Subjunctive] |
| Passover | Pascha | Passover |
| Went out | Eiserchomai | Go [Aorist Active Indicative] |
| Said | Epo | Say [Present Active Indicative] |
| Accusation | Kategoria | Accusation |
| Bring | Phero | Bring, Carry [Present Active Indicative] |
| Against | Kata | Against |
| Man | Anthropos | Man |
| Answered | Apokrinomai | Answer [Aorist Passive Indicative] |
| Said | Epo | Say [Aorist Active Indicative] |
| Were | Eimi | Keep on being [Imperfect Active Indicative] |
| Malefactor | Kakopoios | Evil doer, literally Bad doer, Malefactor |
| Delivered up | Paradidomi | Deliver [Aorist Active Indicative] |
| Said | Epo | Say [Aorist Active Indicative] |
| Take | Lambano | Take [Aorist Active Imperative] |
| Judge | Krino | Judge [Aorist Active Imperative] |
| According | Kata | According to a norm of standard |
| Law | Nomos | Law |
| Said | Epo | Say [Aorist Active Indicative] |
| Lawful | Exesti | Lawful |
| To put to death | Apokteino | To put to death [Aorist Active Infinitive] |
| Any man | Oudeis | Anyone |
| Saying | Logos | Word |
| Might be fulfilled | Pleroo | Fulfil [Aorist Passive Subjunctive] |
| Spake | Epo | Speak [Aorist Active Indicative] |
| Signifying | Semaino | Indicate [Present Active Participle] |
| Death | Thanatos | Death |
| Should | Mello | Should [Imperfect Active Indicative] |
| Die | Apothnesko | Die [Present Active Infinitive] |
| Entered | Eiserchomai | Go [Aorist Active Indicative] |
| Called | Phoneo | Call [Aorist Active Indicative] |
| Said | Epo | Say [Aorist Active Indicative] |
| Art | Eimi | Keep on being [Present Active Indicative] |
| King | Basileus | King |
| Answered | Apokrinomai | Answer [Aorist Passive Indicative] |
| Sayest | Lego | Say [Present Active Indicative] |
| Thing | Touto | This |
| Thyself | Heautou | Yourself |
| Did Others | Allos | Others |
| Tell | Epo | Say [Aorist Active Indicative] |
| Said | Apokrinomai | Answer [Aorist Passive Indicative] |
| Am | Eimi | Keep on being [Present Active Indicative] |
| Nation | Ethnos | Nation, Race |
| Chief Priests | Archiereus | High Priest |
| Have Delivered | Paradidomi | Deliver, Betray [Aorist Active Indicative] |
| Hast Thou Done | Poieo | Do [Aorist Active Indicative] |
| Answered | Apokrinomai | Answer [Aorist Passive Indicative] |
| Kingdom | Basileia | Kingdom |
| Is | Eimi | Keep on being [Present Active Indicative] |
| World | Kosmos | World |
| Were | Eimi | Keep on being [Imperfect Active Indicative] |
| Would my | Emos | My |
| Servants | Huperetes | Servant, Officer |
| Fight | Agonizomai | Strive, Fight [Imperfect Middle Indicative] |
| Should not | Me | Not |
| Be Delivered | Paradidomi | Deliver, Betray [Aorist Passive Subjunctive] |
| Is | Eimi | Keep on being [Present Active Indicative] |
| Hence | Euteuthen | Hence, |
| Said | Epo | Say [Aorist Active Indicative] |
| Art | Eimi | Keep on being [Present Active Indicative] |
| Answered | Apokrinomai | Answer [Aorist Passive Indicative] |
| Sayest | Lego | Say [Present Active Indicative] |
| Am | Eimi | Keep on being [Present Active Indicative] |
| End | Touto | Cause, End |
| Was I born | Gennao | Born [Perfect Passive Indicative] |
| Cause | Touto | Cause, End |
| Came | Erchomai | Come [Perfect Active Indicative] |
| Should bear witness | Martureo | Bear witness [Aorist Active Subjunctive] |
| Truth | Aletheia | Truth |
| Everyone | Pas | All |
| Is | Eimi | Keeps on being [Present Active Participle] |
| Hear | Akouo | Hear [Present Active Indicative] |
| Voice | Phone | Voice |
| Saith | Lego | Say [Present Active Indicative] |
| Is | Eimi | Keeps on being [Present Active Indicative] |
| Had said | Epo | Say [Aorist Active Participle] |
| Went out | Exerchomai | Go out [Aorist Active Indicative] |
| Saith | Lego | Say [Present Active Indicative] |
| Find | Heurisko | Find [Present Active Indicative] |
| No fault | Aitia | Case, Fault, Accusation |
| At All | - | Not found in the original |
PERFECT TENSE VERBS
ERCHOMAI – COME, COME TO PASS – Occurs 641 times in the New Testament with only 21 times in the Perfect Tense. The Perfect Tense is predominantly in the Gospels and always in the Active Voice. It occurs twice in Mark and Acts , four times in Luke, eleven times in John, once in both Philippians and 1 John. Mark 9:13 is the first of a series of perfect tenses which relate to the rejection of God’s Plan. Here Jesus says that Elijah has come but was badly done by and rejected, He further says in Luke 7:33 That John the Baptist was rejected as demon possessed and He Himself rejected as a glutton and winebibber in Luke 7:34.
Jesus said that He had come into the world as the Light John 12:46 but men loved darkness John 3:19, He had come in His Father’s name and had been rejected John 5:43 and that He had come forth from God, but they rejected Him, John 8:42. He had come with a permanent result which had divided the believer and unbeliever.
GENNAO – TO BE BORN – Occurs 97 times in the New Testament with 19 of the occasions being in the Perfect Tense. The Passive voice indicating receiving birth is used on 19 occasions. John dominates this group being recorded 6 times in the Gospel of John and a further 7 times in 1 John. There are 3 occasions in Acts and single references in Galatians, Hebrews and 2 Peter. In John 3:6 the Lord Jesus Christ uses the verb Gennao twice in the Perfect Tense, showing that those born of the flesh remain in the flesh forever and those born of the spirit continue to remain in the spirit.
This indicates to the important fact that all humanity once born exists forever whether in the presence of God or not. In John 3:8 He again refers to the permanence of the spiritual life.
In John 8:42 the Jewish leaders say that they are not illegitimate as they consider Christ to be while in John 9:32 it is noted that the man born blind was always blind. In John 18:37 the Lord Jesus Christ tells Pontius Pilate that He was born to be King, and the results of that will go on forever, with eternal consequences for Pilate and his wife.
OLD TESTAMENT PROPHECY FULFILLED AT THE FIRST COMING OF THE LORD JESUS CHRIST
| ITEM | OLD TESTAMENT | DESCRIPTION | FULFILMENT |
| 155 | Isaiah 55:4a | A witness to His Kingship before Pilate | John 18:37 |
REFLECTION
INTRODUCTION
According to the later Mishnah practices, that were well known and practised at the time of our Lord, there were strict rules to ensure trials were held justly. The Jewish justice system was better and fairer than most modern ones. All these rules were broken during the trials that took place concerning the Lord Jesus Christ. Some of these things were recorded by Rabbi Gamaliel, who had as one of his students Saul of Tarsus, later the Apostle Paul.
The Lord had, in total six trials. The six trials of the Lord Jesus Christ can be divided into two groups; three religious and three civil.
[1] Before Annas John 18:12-14.
[2] Before Caiaphas Matthew 26:57-68
[3] Before the 'rump' Sanhedrin Matthew 27:1-2.
[4] The first trial before Pilate John 18:28-38
[5] The trial before Herod Antipas Luke 23:6-12
[6] The second trial before Pilate. John 18:39-19:6
The Mishnah states in the fourth division section.
1.4 - "Cases involving the death penalty must be tried before 23 judges and for a capital offence it must be before the full Sanhedrin with at least 71 members.
1.5 - " To judge a false prophet there needs to be at least 71 members. Included in this must be the High Priest, judges and others".
3.4, 3.5 “Anyone who is a witness or is a judge is disqualified as being a judge or a witness if they play dice or loan money or if they race pigeons or if they do any business on the Sabbath. They are also prohibited from serving as a witness if they are a relative, a friend or known to be an enemy of the accused"
In the case of three religious trials of the Lord Jesus Christ the trials were by these rules invalid as they stated that they wanted to kill this man. Three more sections of the Mishna make it clear that the rules were broken even more.
4.5 - the witness in a capital offence trial was warned that "perhaps it is your intention of giving testimony on the basis of supposition or on the basis of what another witness has told you. You may be thinking that you have heard this from a reliable person”. They would test in detail the witnesses. The major threat to the witness was that the blood of the innocent man would be on them if they lie.
3.8 - If a person who was guilty said that he was innocent and said that he could bring proof he was given 30 days to do that.
5.1 - there were seven questions to be asked of the witness. In what period of seven years, one year, month, day, what day of the week at what time of the day and where did it occur. The witness had to be specific. It was stated that the more the witness was questioned the more the judge should be praised.
In the Four Gospel account many witnesses were investigated, and none were found that did not contradict one another. According to the rules the person accused had to be released at that point or given the 30 days to prove his innocence if witnesses came forward.
Mishna 5.5 - There must be at least three witnesses. If the man is found innocent they are to send him away, if not, they are to postpone judging him to the next day. They were to leave the court in pairs and not to eat or drink for the entire day, they were to discuss the matter all the next night and then come back for the sentence the day after.
6.1 - When the person was convicted the person was to be taken out and stoned. If on the way to be executed he says that he has something to say in his favour they are to bring him back. This can be done 4-5 times.
6.4 - shows how the person is to be stoned and only the blasphemer is then hanged on the tree.
7.5 - the one who blasphemes will only be liable when he has fully pronounced the divine name. It was sacrilegious to use the name of God. (The liberals today argue that it was pronounced Yahweh rather than Jehovah.) Anyone who tried to pronounce the name was stoned to death.
In a case of blasphemy, they would bring in only the oldest witness to a court that had been cleared and he was told to say exactly what the accused had said in detail. The judges stand on their feet and tear their clothing and never sew them up again.
The second and third witness would come in and say that they heard what the first witness had heard. When they ripped their clothes at the trial of Jesus the Sanhedrin were saying that they believed he had committed blasphemy, but they did not convict him on the basis of witnesses.
No trial was to be held at night; it always had to be put off to the next day.
Let us go through the record of the trials and see other things about them from the Mishnah's perspective.
John 18:12 - 24 The trial before Annas, who was not the High Priest of that year, but as a previous high priest, according to the Mishnah, he held that title until his death. Caiaphas was the man wearing the mitre. He had replaced his father-in-law at the instigation of the Romans. In orthodox teaching Annas was still high priest and he is recognised as such by John.
Matthew 26:57-68 This tells us the whole story from Matthew’s memory of events. John does not repeat it. Here it says he was taken to Caiaphas but as father and son in law, both Annas and Caiaphas would have been in the same compound with a shared courtyard. John was supplementing what Matthew was saying. This indicates the reliability and genuineness of the eyewitness of the Gospel writers.
In verses 60 and 61 they attempt to get witnesses to condemn him. They found two witnesses. In verse 62 the High Priest asked the Lord to comment on the evidence (which is against the Mishna, as no-one was ever to be asked to give evidence against himself).
He asks the Lord if He is the Son of God, finds Him guilty and rips the High Priest's clothes which were never to be ripped [Leviticus 21:10), although the other present were expected to rip their garments once the blasphemy was heard.
He pronounces the death penalty, which was against the Mishnah rules. For the death penalty the verdict had to be held over for a day and a night, and the Sanhedrin had to give its verdict starting from the youngest and going up to the oldest. They beat the Lord in advance of the trial before the Sanhedrin in Matthew 27:1-2, and send him there to endorse the findings of the High Priest's court. However, in Jewish time it was still the same day as the Jewish day started at 6 pm, and such action was illegal. The whole trial was illegal in accord with Exodus 23:8, for it had been set in place by a bribe.
In Matthew Peter's denial appears to occur during the Lord's trial before Caiaphas whereas the account in John shows it to be during the trial before Annas. This is not an anomaly as Peter is in the common courtyard and the denials occur during the time the Lord is being tried by the two men.
John 18:27 - gives the time of the completion of the second trial. The cock crowing was the Roman trumpet to show the changes of the Roman guard from the first watch. 'Cock crow' was the name for the watch, or guard group, that went from midnight to 3 am. The time at this point is fixed at exactly 3am.
John 18:28 - we see He is led into the “Hall of Judgement” and it was 'early'. John gives us Roman time in his Gospel, as the Lord was executed under their law, and the people John writes to are living in the Roman Empire and understood this way of telling time. 'Early' is not a reference to relative time of day as such but is actually the specific name for the next Roman watch. 'Early' was 3 to 6 am. When Jesus was brought to Pilate it was between 3 and 6 am, it was the early watch.
The watches then were called '3rd hour' (6 -9 am), '6th hour' (9 am - noon), and '9th hour' (noon - 3 pm), the 'twelfth hour' (3 - 6 pm). We are on a strict timetable with these trials, for the Lord must be executed before the Passover is slain at 3pm that day, or he will have to be held over until after the feast, and a full trial held again more than seven days later.
According to the Law he should have been held over, but the High Priests are running things their way not according to the rules of law, yet precisely in God’s time. Remember also, in Jewish time, there were two evenings; the evening of the first day which was between 3 and 6 pm and the evening off the following day which was between 6 pm and the time the sun went down. So, in Jewish reckoning each afternoon you had two evenings, 3 - 6pm was the last evening of the day that ended at 6pm, and at one minute after 6pm you entered the first evening of the next day.
The Passover lamb is to be slain 'between the evenings', that is at any time from 3pm until 9pm.
Pilate has the impatience of the new rich Italian upper classes, and also the Roman hatred for the Jews who they saw as a people obsessed with religious nonsense. The Romans were very tolerant of religions and could not understand anything religious that was not tolerant. Judaism was not tolerant, it was legalistic and absolute in its claims, and the Romans saw it as a divisive force. They felt that the Jews were a people always ready to rebel, always ready to sacrifice themselves for a religious cause, a nation of fanatics.
Verse 28. Then led they Jesus from Caiaphas unto the hall of judgment: and it was early; and they themselves went not into the judgment hall, lest they should be defiled; but that they might eat the passover.
The religious trial has ended, and the civil trial is about to begin. The scene is the Hall of Judgement or the palace of the governor. The Jews did not want to go into the palace of the Gentile. They believed that they would be defiled and would thus be prevented from eating the Passover. As we have seen, It does not seem to bother them that they were plotting of the death of the Son of God. It would have been a tragedy for them to enter Gentile house, but murder was a mere trifle. How deceived Satan makes the determined unsaved – for their values reflect the temporary issues of wealth, status, power and wealth.
Verse 29. Pilate then went out unto them, and said, What accusation bring ye against this man? 30 They answered and said unto him, If he were not a malefactor, we would not have delivered him up unto thee.
Pilate, the Roman Procurator gave in to the religious scruples of the Jews, by going out to where they were, and in this he identifies his weakness and their strength – they have him where they want him – but he can still order Jesus’ arrest and being held over until after the Feast – but he does not. He began this next fake trial by asking them to state their charge against this prisoner.
Their answer was bold and rude. They said in effect that they had already tried the case and found Him guilty. All they want Pilate to do was to pronounce a sentence. “Get your rubber stamp out and condemn him!” This expresses their contempt for Pilate and Rome, but also their weakness this day – they need him to take responsibility. They know there are three quick executions planned for the morning, of three terrorists (freedom fighters), just as a warning to any would be radicals that Rome was “getting tough” on radicalism.
Verse 31. Then said Pilate unto them, Take ye him, and judge him according to your law. The Jews therefore said unto him, It is not lawful for us to put any man to death: 32 That the saying of Jesus might be fulfilled, which he spake, signifying what death he should die.
Pilate tried to evade responsibility for Jesus and throw it back on the Jews. If they had already tried Jesus and found him guilty then why did they not sentence Him according to their law? The answer of the Jews was very significant. They recognised that they were not independent of Rome. They have been taken over by Roman power. They had denied they were in bondage to any man, and yet here they are acknowledging their servitude. John 8:33.
Civil government has been taken from their hands, and they were no longer able to put anyone to death. Their answer was evidence of their bondage and subjection to the Gentile power. Furthermore, they wanted to shift the odium of Christ’s death onto Pilate, as they did the death of John the Baptist to Herod Antipas.
Verse 32 may have two different meanings. In Matthew 20:19 Jesus had predicted that he would have be delivered up to the Gentiles to be killed. Here the Jewish authorities were doing that very thing to Him.
Secondly in many places the Lord said that He would be lifted up. This referred to death by crucifixion. The Jews used stoning in case of capital punishment, whereas crucifixion was the Roman method for non-citizens. Thus, by handing over the Lord Jesus Christ to Pilate the Jews unknowingly fulfilled these two prophecies concerning the Messiah.
Verse 33. Then Pilate entered into the judgment hall again, and called Jesus, and said unto him, Art thou the King of the Jews? 34 Jesus answered him, Sayest thou this thing of thyself, or did others tell it thee of me? 35 Pilate answered, Am I a Jew? Thine own nation and the chief priests have delivered thee unto me: what hast thou done? 36 Jesus answered, My kingdom is not of this world: if my kingdom were of this world, then would my servants fight, that I should not be delivered to the Jews: but now is my kingdom not from hence.
Pilate tries to get the Jewish leaders to deal with Jesus themselves, then he impatiently asks Jesus to condemn Himself (in verse 33), and Jesus’ reply would have stung him, for he knew he had violated Roman law by asking such a question.
Pilate's response in verse 35 shows just how strong his hatred was for this whole performance. Self interest is driving him not justice, but he lacks the moral courage to acquit the Lord. He is vulnerable to the complaints of the Jewish authorities, and he knows it – and he saves himself, but only for a few years.
He just wants the whole thing to go away, and the death of the Lord is finally of no concern to him, even though he knows He is a just and innocent man. In Pilate's eyes Jesus is just another Jewish religious nuisance. He despises the Jewish people, the Lord’s message and the true messenger of God, and he is in Hell today thinking about this! All who treat the Lord and his message as if it is a nuisance are in the company of this man!
Pilate has asked, 'what have you done?' His spies have not turned up anything that worries him as a Roman ruler. Jesus’ answer does not solve Pilate's problem, but it confronts him with the real issue. Look at the words of the Lord in relations to Pilate's question. Re-read both verses. What has he done? He has made an issue of eternity and the claims of God over the matters of time. He has made God's claim to rulership over the lives of men clear.
By his presence and message, He demands that all people chose between obedience to the Lord, and the demands of Satan's 'Cosmos' system to follow self-centred power and influence upon the earth. Both the religious leaders and Pilate have chosen their path and will remain obedient to the demand of the Satanic Cosmos system. They will choose the way that maintains their power and temporary life-style on earth, rather than the way that expresses obedience to the Lord God of eternity.
Jesus also makes it clear in his answer that he is no revolutionary. Very strongly He says that His servants will not fight for Him, for His kingdom is, 'not of this world'. The phrase used here means, 'not ever, no way; it will never be the case that the kingdom of Jesus is of this world system'. Jesus has no part in the cosmos system of self-centred violent power that Satan runs upon the earth. Jesus will rule upon the earth, but only through the judgement of the cosmos system, and after evil's total destruction.
Pilate had lots of experience as a soldier. He understands the Lord's words, that if His kingdom was of this world His servants would be fighting now! Jesus’ point is clear. If Jesus had been a political figure, He would have had His guards and would have camped on the hills so that His followers could resist any arrest attempt.
If He was a political figure His servants would have been organising themselves at this very moment and their torches would be seen coming across the Kidron Valley into the city now to demand His release. As neither of these things has happened it follows that He cannot be a political figure, especially not a dangerous, organised revolutionary, like the three men scheduled for execution that day. Jesus is no Barabbas.
Verse 37. Pilate therefore said unto him, Art thou a king then? Jesus answered, Thou sayest that I am a king. To this end was I born, and for this cause came I into the world, that I should bear witness unto the truth. Every one that is of the truth heareth my voice.
Pilate is desperate for something to condemn him on and get back to sleep, then his pleasant wealthy lifestyle! He seizes on the word 'King'. Once again Jesus’ answer rebukes Pilate in all he has said, and in his devious way of questioning the Lord. Roman justice prided itself on the pursuit of 'TRUTH', and so the Lord uses that word (Latin - 'VERITAS') to underline the injustice and deviousness of the proceedings. The Lord's answer indicates three things about Pilate's question.
1. 'Thou sayest' - in effect the Lord is saying, 'you have already found me guilty'.
2. 'This is why I came' - God's plan calls for my death and your rebellion against the truth will be used by God to fulfil this plan. All our sins put the Lord on the cross, but Pilate and the Priests specific sin will directly lead to it, even against the odds (for his death violates both Roman and Jewish Law).
3. 'All who love truth hear my words' - attitude to the Lord shows attitude to the truth generally.
Unbelievers may say they love the truth, but they love a lie if they hate the Lord! Pilate shows his cynical attitude to life itself by his response in the next verse.
Verse 38. Pilate saith unto him, What is truth? And when he had said this, he went out again unto the Jews, and saith unto them, I find in him no fault at all.
These are not the words of a philosopher; they are the words of a cynical soldier politician. He dismisses the Lord with a cynical wave of his hand. Pilate knows there is no fault in the Lord, and at this point Roman justice demands He be released. The order should have been given now. 'Release the prisoner, all people are to return to their homes, guards disperse the crowd!'
He is not going to do this for he fears the crowd and believes, with good reason that the priests have prepared a riot if he doesn't do what they want. In any other year he would have used his troops, but he is under a warning from the governor of Syria this year! The timing of the cross is perfect, in any other year it would not have happened. He now proceeds to a bargaining approach that is unheard of for a Roman ruler to use, but he is desperate to avoid trouble and another complaint that will be fatal to his career and money flow.

