Harmony of the Gospels · Betrayal and Trials · Lesson 7 of 20

The Agony in the Garden, part 5: John 18:1-12

About 23 min read

Text size
🎧 Listen to the lectures for this course (3)

All the lectures for this course

Dr John McEwan's recorded lectures. Tap Listen, then press play. You can keep reading while it plays.

  1. Betrayal and Trials Lectures 147-149
  2. Betrayal and Trials Lectures 149-151
  3. Betrayal and Trials Lectures 152-156

JOHN 18:1-12

John 18:1 When Jesus had spoken these words, he went forth with his disciples over the brook Cedron, where was a garden, into the which he entered, and his disciples. 2 And Judas also, which betrayed him, knew the place: for Jesus ofttimes resorted thither with his disciples. 3 Judas then, having received a band of men and officers from the chief priests and Pharisees, cometh thither with lanterns and torches and weapons. 4 Jesus therefore, knowing all things that should come upon him, went forth, and said unto them, Whom seek ye? 5 They answered him, Jesus of Nazareth. Jesus saith unto them, I am he. And Judas also, which betrayed him, stood with them. 6 As soon then as he had said unto them, I am he, they went backward, and fell to the ground. 7 Then asked he them again, Whom seek ye? And they said, Jesus of Nazareth. 8 Jesus answered, I have told you that I am he: if therefore ye seek me, let these go their way: 9 That the saying might be fulfilled, which he spake, Of them which thou gavest me have I lost none. 10 Then Simon Peter having a sword drew it, and smote the high priest's servant, and cut off his right ear. The servant's name was Malchus. 11 Then said Jesus unto Peter, Put up thy sword into the sheath: the cup which my Father hath given me, shall I not drink it?

KEY WORDS

Betrayed Paradidomi Betray [Present Active Participle]
Knew Eido Perceive, Know [Pluperfect Active Indicative]
Place Topos Place, Location
Ofttimes Pollakis Many times, Often
Resorted Sunago Come together [Aorist Passive Indicative]
Disciples Mathetes Disciple
Received Lambano Receive [Aorist Active Participle]
Band Speira Band
Men - Not found in the original
Officers Huperetes Officer
Chief Priests Archiereus Chief Priest
Cometh Erchomai Come [Present Middle Indicative]
Lanterns Phanos Lantern
Torches Lampas Lamps
Weapons Hoplon Weapon
Knowing Eido Know [Perfect Active Participle]
All things Pas All
Should come Erchomai Come [Present Middle Participle]
Went forth Exerchomai Go out [Aorist Active Indicative]
Said Lego Say [Present Active Indicative]
Seek Zeteo Seek [Present Active Indicative]
Answered Apokrinomai Answer [Aorist Passive Indicative]
Saith Lego Say [Present Active Indicative]
I Am Ego Eimi I keep on being [Present Active Indicative]
He - Not found in the original
Betrayed Paradidomi Betray [Present Active Participle]
Stood Histemi Stand
As soon as Hos Oon With all speed, As soon as
Said Epo Say [Aorist Active Indicative]
I am Ego Eimi I keep on being [Present Active Indicative]
Went Aperchomai Depart [Aorist Active Indicative]
Backward Eis Opiso Backwards
Fell Pipto Fall [Aorist Active Indicative]
Ground Chamai On to the ground
Asked Eperotao Ask, Request [Aorist Active Indicative]
Seek Zeteo Seek [Present Active Indicative]
Said Epo Say [Aorist Active Indicative]
Answered Apokrinomai Answer [Aorist Passive Indicative]
Told Epo Tell, Say [Aorist Active Indicative]
Am Eimi Keep on being [Present Active Indicative]
Seek Zeteo Seek [Present Active Indicative]
Let Aphiemi Let [Aorist Active Imperative]
Go their way Hupago Go their way [Present Active Infinitive]
Saying Logos Word
Fulfilled Pleroo Fulfil [Aorist Passive Subjunctive]
Spake Epo Speak, Say [Aorist Active Indicative]
Gavest Didomi Give [Perfect Active Indicative]
Lost Apollumi Lose [Aorist Active Indicative]
Having Echo Have and hold [Present Active Participle]
Sword Machaira Sword
Drew Helkuo Draw [Aorist Active Indicative]
Smote Paio Strike, Smite [Aorist Active Indicative]
Servant Doulos Slave, Servant
Cut off Aphaireo Cut off, Remove [Aorist Active Indicative]
Right Dexios Right
Ear Otion Ear
Name Onoma Name
Was Eimi Keep on being [Imperfect Active Indicative]
Said Epo Say [Aorist Active Indicative]
Put up Ballo Throw [Aorist Active Imperative]
Sheath Theke Scabbard, Sheath
Cup Poterion Cup
Father Pater Father
Given Didomi Give [Perfect Active Indicative]
Shall I not Ou Me Not at all
Drink Pino Drink [Aorist Active Subjunctive]
Captain Chiliarchos Captain, Colonel
Took Sullambano Take, Seize [Aorist Active Indicative]
Bound Deo Bind [Aorist Active Indicative]

PERFECT TENSE VERBS

DIDOMI - GIVE occurs 413 times in the New Testament with 36 times in the Perfect Tense. On 26 occasions it is in the Active Voice leaving 10 in the Passive. The vast majority of the Perfect Tenses occur in the Gospel of John with 24 and with 3 in I John accounts for 75% of the occurrences.

OIDA, EIDO – TO KNOW – Occurs 251 times in the Perfect Tense in the New Testament and is by far the largest with Grapho next at 96 occurrences. Because of the mixture of “knows” and “don’t knows” and different characters ranging from the Trinity, through the Disciples of Christ, Religious Leaders, and even to demons the review of this verb is given in a segregated form.

OLD TESTAMENT PROPHECY FULFILLED AT THE FIRST COMING OF THE LORD JESUS CHRIST

ITEM OLD TESTAMENT DESCRIPTION FULFILMENT
149 Psalm 40:14 Confronted by adversaries in the garden John 18:4-6
Psalm 69:26 The Saviour given and smitten by God John 18:11
Isaiah 53:10a God’s will that He die for mankind John 18:11
Zechariah 13:7a God’s will that He die for mankind John 18:11

REFLECTION

Verse 2. And Judas also, which betrayed him, knew the place: for Jesus ofttimes resorted thither with his disciples.3 Judas then, having received a band of men and officers from the chief priests and Pharisees, cometh thither with lanterns and torches and weapons.

In these verses a band of soldiers has been given to Judas and he has headed out to arrest Jesus. The word for band is "speira" which means a cohort or 600 men. A battalion of men has been sent to arrest the Lord. The Roman band then has the Temple Police contingent in addition to do the arrest, and it includes Temple and Roman military officers and some of the High Priest's officials. Here we have representatives of both the Jewish/Roman political and Jewish religious systems.

Pilate was involved from the beginning in this unjust exercise. The Roman cohort is there to stop any possible unrest and be able to fight their way out of trouble. Passover was a time when the whole place could erupt in problems. In AD 66 at Passover the Jewish Revolt will begin. No accident here that the exact season of the betrayal of the Messiah is the season for final rebellion against Rome. There may be 1000 armed men here to arrest the Lord, and possibly the disciples as well.

Pilate could not allow any riot to happen as he was on his last warning from the Roman Senate due to earlier problems he had been involved with. The population of Jerusalem was swollen from 100,000 to well over 1 million at that time of year. You had a vast tent city at this time on all the hills including this one. Pilate had a good reason to be concerned, but he will still not heed his wife’s warning, nor follow justice and morality.

It was not going to be easy to find Jesus in this sea of humanity, and if the crowd rose up to protect Him the soldiers would have been overwhelmed and a full revolt could have started. The Roman troops have their orders; they are to go in there with Judas, march quietly, no shouting, quickly arrive, ensure the Temple Guard make the arrest, grab any followers they can, but don't wait around - they are to get out of there quickly and report back to Pilate on the political-revolt situation! They do not see this as a spiritual matter.

Every governor had his spies. He needed to hear what was happening. It is apparent that Jesus was portrayed as a potential trouble-maker, and that He needed to be put out of the way. Pilate was not surprised to be woken up early to try the case; he’s been up for hours, as he would have had to give the order to make the arrest in the first place.

After the arrest his cohort commander would have given Pilate a report saying that Jesus was no problem as His followers had fled and He had come quietly. The cohort had orders to ensure the prisoner was under the care of the Temple guards at all points, as it was a 'religious matter' and Pilate probably hoped they would sort it out and be blamed. He also knew that religious matters in Palestine had the potential to become political. It was a volatile country, and Passover was a volatile time.

Note that they came out with torches and weapons. They came out with small and large torches. They used a handheld olive oil burning type and large pitch covered poles. They come prepared. They come with the heavily armed infantry. These were heavily armed, battle ready and battle-hardened soldiers. There may also have been three hundred or more Temple guards, Jews who guarded the Temple, but a cohort of Roman auxiliaries may also have come. There were probably closer to one thousand men coming to arrest the Lord. They were ready for major trouble.

Judas knew where the Lord would be, once he discovered the Upper Room and other key houses empty. He went there first. How do we know? Because he wakes up a young man at one house and this young man runs semi dressed through the streets to try to get to the Lord first to warn Him. That young man is John Mark, as John-Mark’s house was close by the temple. Our suspicion is that Judas had to go to several places to ensure Jesus had not slipped away from the Upper Room to another place before leaving the city.

Mark and Judas knew that Jesus never slept in the city overnight, but always in this Garden or at Bethany. The reason, He would not stay in the city of David unless as King. If he was not to be accepted as King and Lord, He would not rest his head there. Judas motive for betrayal is mentioned here.

What was going on in Judas' mind? We cannot know, except that he did not accept the Lord's words about His upcoming death. Judas wanted power and money and influence, and when the Lord made it clear that this was not on His agenda, Judas betrayed the Lord. Maybe he did this to try to force the Lord’s hand to raise the revolt against the Romans, that Judas knew He could have, and with the power Jesus had shown He had over nature and men, Judas may have expected Jesus to “flash forth” His power and it was then all on.

Jesus would “flash forth” His glory once this night (below) and the entire contingent of soldiers falls backwards including Judas. Imagine the noise of that, the swearing and disorder for a few seconds, all of which wakes the thousands of sleeping pilgrims – anything can happen…

Judas wanted Jesus on his terms, and this is exactly the sinful error of unbelievers still! They either want nothing to do with Jesus, or they want Him on their terms, but they will not accept Him as Lord of their life, for they wish to run their own affairs, and live their own way! Judas sin is power-lust and pride, it is self centeredness; it is living for himself rather than living for God.

Whatever was on Judas' mind the evil result was the betrayal of the Lord of glory and his own eternal damnation. We face this issue daily at a lesser level – will we live God’s way or our own? Will we accomplish our part in the plan and win eternal rewards, or will be make “helpful suggestions” to the Lord and call them prayer requests?

Verse 4. Jesus therefore, knowing all things that should come upon him, went forth, and said unto them, Whom seek ye? 5 They answered him, Jesus of Nazareth. Jesus saith unto them, I am he. And Judas also, which betrayed him, stood with them. 6 As soon then as he had said unto them, I am he, they went backward, and fell to the ground.

In verse 4 the Lord comes out to meet them. He went out knowing all things that should come upon Him. He asked them, 'who is it you want?' The deity of Christ is in focus here. There are no surprises here. He knows God's plan is going to succeed, He is in control! He was in control of history this night, and He still is today.

This was a walled garden. The Lord goes through the gate to talk to the soldiers. The disciples have a wall between them and the soldiers. Probably only Peter, or James and John also, goes beyond the wall. The Lord's action guarantees all their safety; they have the way of escape open, and they take it and are off. Only John and Peter will follow the Lord into the city after the arresting group, who will “double-march” away getting back to the temple compound in a few minutes before any riot can happen on the Mount of Olives.

The Lord says, “Who are you seeking?” It was a full moon at Passover time, so it must have been darkly overcast and these torches were not the most efficient method of finding people. This indicates that the Lord and the disciples could have easily got away. There was not a lot of visibility, the Father made sure of that. Jesus is not going to slip away this night – it is the time for Him to fulfil His destiny and pay for our sins. He could have escaped, but he doesn’t.

It is the time for the Cross; the Cross was not an accident. It was part of the Eternal Plan and as such God is in control of the whole thing, and the Lord is setting his face towards it here. John 7:6, 30, 8:20 make the point that if the time is right the plan gets done, and the work will be done for our salvation this day.

In verse 5 they say that they seek Jesus the Nazarene. Jesus says, “I am he”. Even Judas did not recognise the Lord until he came forward to meet them. He is recognised as Jesus of Nazareth. He says, "I AM". This title signifies deity. Notice that the word “he” is not in the original. Jesus is using the name of Jehovah showing He is God.

As a result of the words the entire company of soldiers went backwards and fell to the ground. For an instant His deity flashed out and it demolished the army. The Romans were in deep trouble at this point, as they were on their backs in full armour.

Jesus shows that he has the power to resist if he wants to. Matthew 26:53 says that if he had asked for it, he could have had twelve legions of angels, or 72,000 angels, to assist Him. God is in control and while this may appear to be a tragedy unfolding now, it is part of the plan, and the flashing forth for this moment shows His power and majesty and that this is His purpose! Again, and again this night, the door to escape is open and Our Lord walks steadily towards the Cross, with every opportunity to flee a real one.

Verse 7. Then asked he them again, Whom seek ye? And they said, Jesus of Nazareth. 8 Jesus answered, I have told you that I am he: if therefore ye seek me, let these go their way: 9 That the saying might be fulfilled, which he spake, Of them which thou gavest me have I lost none.

They get up looking apprehensively around. Put yourself in the picture here! You are one of those soldiers, you are in a place where you know that over 100,000 Jewish people were asleep. There might be various factions amongst them, but all of them hate Romans! You have just had over 600 heavily armed men fall over; you now have the sleeping crowd waking up. The valley would have been filled with the cries of the waking people wondering what was going on lighting lamps to try to see into the darkness and assess the threat to themselves.

The Romans are in deep trouble, they don't want to wait around here! Their fear and confusion is shown by the fact that the Lord has to refocus them, and says again, 'whom do you seek?' and again they say, Jesus of Nazareth and again he says, I AM. The other Gospel writers tell us that Judas came forward and gave Him the traitors kiss at this point.

When you see the kiss in its context it is a truly pathetic thing! Judas and the entire group have been flattened, so it is clear who Jesus is and what He is, and yet Judas comes forward and plays his part – he is a true “play-actor”.

John still remembers the Lord's next words, 'If therefore you seek Me let these go their way'. His concern is for the disciples, so that He would lose none of them. It is interesting that even after Peter's provocation they all got away, and that flash of deity ensured the Romans were wanting to be back in the Antonia Fortress and would have been “at the double” all the way back. Peter’s next action just delays things a few seconds.

Verse 10. Then Simon Peter having a sword drew it, and smote the high priest's servant, and cut off his right ear. The servant's name was Malchus. 11 Then said Jesus unto Peter, Put up thy sword into the sheath: the cup which my Father hath given me, shall I not drink it?

Peter is going to die some 37 years later. It is not his time to die but it is the Lord's time to die. He protects His disciples. Peter decides that it is not time for the Lord to die so he tries to chop the High Priest's servant's head off but he ducks sideways and Peter misses and slices off an ear. John knows the family of the High Priest and notes that the servant's name is Malchus. The fact that John mentions his name may indicate that he eventually became a believer (note in Luke that he was healed at this point, instantly defusing the situation).

The Lord makes it very clear that He is in charge, and that these who arrest Him are the children of darkness, yet still he will act to demonstrate, to the Jewish men at least, that He is the Saviour. They are coming with inferior lights to treat unjustly the light of the world.

In verse 11 Peter is rebuked and is told that the Cross is part of God's Plan and you have no business trying to stop it with a sword. We must follow the Lord's will. Peter tried his best, but the Lord doesn’t want us to “do our best”, he wanted Peter to be obedient, not to try his best in human strength and human thinking. Isaiah 55:6-11, Jeremiah 10:23-24.

Here we are reminded of the Lord's control over the events leading to the Cross. He has a cup to drink, and He will drink it to the last drop, for our salvation rests upon His completion of the task, and He will affirm, “It is Finished!” and it will be. The time for His arrest has come, and so He lets it occur.

Judas’ pathetic sin of betrayal and Peter's enthusiastic, if misguided defence, have been contrasted here. Both are wrong in their thinking, actions and conclusions, but Peter's love for the Lord and the Lord's provisions for Him will lead to his stability and comfort. Judas is the son of perdition by his own choices; he has rejected love right to the end and chooses suicide rather than repentance.

Verse 12. Then the band and the captain and officers of the Jews took Jesus, and bound him,

The Lord allows this to happen, but it is not a quiet 'considerate' arrest. The Romans or Temple Police are very brutal in the arrest itself. The Lord is thrown to the ground and considerable force is used on the Lord and his is painfully bound with his arms pinned behind his back. Probably as a bundle, as Paul will also later be bound, Acts 21:32-36, he is carried by the cohort back to the High Priest’s house, where the Romans will “peel off” and head directly into the Fortress Antonia, leaving the Temple Guard to do the rest.

APPLICATION

In the case of Judas, he told the Temple Guards to restrain the Lord, as he was afraid of reprisals. Those who have criminal or bad attitudes often expect others to react as they would. We need to respond as our Lord would and not react to situations according to our Old Sin Nature. Judas betrays his total lack of understanding of the Lord right to the pathetic end of his life.

Pettiness of attitude is eliminated by the application of the Word of God to one’s life.

Neither the ignorant believer nor the arrogant unbeliever can hinder the Plan of God, although at times it may seem like it, like in Peter’s case, while at times God will even use the free will actions of an unbeliever as an integral part of His plan.

Self centred people value things that they can lose, and the fickle praises of man, rather than the 'well done' of God, for that is just too far away for them.

Let us learn from the sin of Judas and foolishness of Peter. As believers we are not like Judas, but we may resemble him or Peter at times, when we place our ideas of what might be “right to do” above the will of the Lord for our lives.

Remember the principle; if you are in a situation where the Lord wants you, He will protect you until you have completed the task. You need to ask, “Am I doing what the Lord would have me do?" Listen, Relax and Obey – “just do it”!

If you are in the Plan of God, you are safe, and even if you are out of the will of God at that point, you may well be as safe as Peter was here. If He wants you to be a martyr give Him thanks that you have been given the opportunity to gain the martyr’s crown before you go to be with Him forever. Find out what He wants you to do and do it without fear. Saturate each moment with prayerfulness.

God doesn't want us to give our human best! He wants us to be obedient to Him and follow the Holy Spirit and give our supernatural spiritual best! Our human strength and our human outrage at sin is worthless puffery; Holy Spirit power and God’s Plan for our life alone has the power we need leading towards the Second Advent.

DOCTRINES

REVOLUTION

1. The Word of God does not justify revolution (Numbers 16).

2. Revolution involves mobs which can neither think nor achieve anything worthwhile.

3. Revolution means apostasy and lack of the Word of God (Isaiah 1:3-5; 59:13).

4. Revolution is anti-God (Isaiah 31:6).

5. Revolution is always caused by some failure of the mind (Jeremiah 5:23) e.g. maximum mental sins, drug addiction, alcoholism, lack of morals.

6. Jealousy is a motivator of revolution. (Isaiah 11:13 cf. 1 Kings 12:19; 2 Chronicles 10:19).

7. When Bible doctrine is communicated it tends to stop revolution (Ezekiel 2:3-10) e.g. in England in the 18th and 19th centuries there were no revolutions. In Europe, however, with the lack of doctrine, many revolutions occurred.

8. Principle:

a) When human power and privileges are monopolised by a few, the people become oppressed. (1 Kings 21:1-16; 1 Samuel 8-11-19).

b) Limited in freedom and opportunity, they become slaves, even though they may not have shackles.

c) Anything accomplished by revolution could have been accomplished without revolution and therefore could have been undertaken in a stabilised form e.g. the reforms in Britain during the 19th century.

d) National trauma occurs in revolution as it is a sharp break with the past.

JUDAS - BETRAYAL

1. SCRIPTURE Matthew 26:14-16, 25; 27:3-10. Mark 14:1-11. Luke 22:3-6. John 12:3-6; 13:2, 27-30, Acts 1:18, 19.

2. BIOGRAPHY

Judas was one of the twelve disciples of Jesus Christ. He was the son of Simon (John 6:71) and was known as Judas Iscariot. Iscariot indicates that he was from Kerioth which was located in Moab (Jeremiah 48:24, 41 Amos 2:2) or Kerioth Hezron (Joshua 15:25) which was situated 20 kilometres south of Hebron. Judas was the treasurer (John 13:29) and was also a thief (John 12:6). It was Judas who criticised Mary when she anointed the Lord with precious ointment (John 12 3-5). The ointment he saw as a source of income.

His avarice eventually became so overpowering that he conspired with the religious leaders of the time to betray Jesus. He did not understand the whole implications of his action because when he saw what the authorities were doing to Jesus Christ, he felt sorry for his actions and eventually committed suicide (Acts 1:18,19).

3. EVALUATION

a) Judas always appeared last on the list of disciples (Mark 3:14-19).

b) He was described as a traitor (Luke 6:16) and betrayer (Matthew 10:4).

c) Judas was an unbeliever who did not address Jesus as Lord (Kurios) but Rabbi - Teacher (Matthew 26:25).

d) At Simon the leper's house, Mary came and anointed the feet of Jesus with ointment while they were eating (Mark 14:3).

e) The disciples, led by Judas, complained about the waste of money, estimating it at a year's salary (Mark 14:5).

f) After this Judas left to barter with the chief priests to betray Jesus (Mark 14:10, 11; Zechariah 11:12; Exodus 21:32).

g) At the last supper, Jesus gave Judas his last chance to be saved when he offered the sop, a portion of food reserved for honoured guests (John 13:26).

h) Judas rejected Jesus and was then indwelt by Satan (John 13:27). He then went to betray Jesus.

i) Judas betrayed Jesus with a kiss (Matthew 26:47-50).

j) When Judas saw that Jesus was to be condemned he felt sorry (Metamelomai, Gk.) for what he had done (Matthew 27:3) but did not repent (Metanoeo, Gk.) or change his mind about Jesus Christ (2 Corinthians 7:10).

k) He went and hanged himself (Matthew 27:5) and his body fell into the Kidron Valley (Acts 1:18, 19), at Alcadema - the field of blood (Zechariah 11:12, 13).

4. PRINCIPLES

a) We should not doubt the Lord's sincerity in calling Judas to be a disciple. Jesus appealed to Judas on many occasions to believe in Him (2 Peter 3:9).

b) Jesus' fore-knowledge does not imply fore-ordination that Judas must become the traitor.

Text size

Course text © Evangelical Bible College of Western Australia, shared with their permission. Bible quotations are mostly from the King James Version, as in the original. Back to all courses