THEMES
The first letter is clearly facing the issues of faith under pressure and its key word is hope. The believers are encouraged to focus on the eternal life perspective on their present troubles. The Christian’s perspective must always be eternal, if we are to be strong and stable, for our journey to towards heaven not focused on earth.
We have a task here, God’s assigned task in His Plan, but no continuing city here! We are called to do the work of the Lord to fulfill our part in the divine plan, at our time and place in history, but our hope and destiny is in heaven not upon the earth. The believers are called to reclaim the resources of their faith and see that in suffering they have the opportunity to share the experience of their Lord. Under pressures of persecution we become partakers of Christ’s suffering (1 Peter 2:19-21, 4:12-15, Philippians 3:10, and Colossians 1:24-26), and in this there is learning that would not otherwise come in time, and a joy that will last throughout eternity!
“Saint Peter is bidding his readers look at their troubles in the light of their glorious destiny, and so to chart their lives, that is to say, on a large map”. (Selwyn, 1952, p 79.) The church was not to seek out persecution and not to set out to cause offence, but when the inevitable attacks came, they were to stand firm and focus on the eternal issues at stake rather than their temporal lives. This remains our challenge!
In the midst of talk of suffering Peter emphasises the sovereignty of God. In 1 Peter 1:2 and 2:9, he reminds us that God has his hand on history and that all that comes to us comes under the principle of 1 Corinthians 10:13. “It is the epistle for afflicted believers, a wilderness Epistle. It pictures the believers as journeying on from the place of the blood sprinkling to the inheritance in heaven, or from the cross to the glory. It pictures a pilgrim people, strangers passing through an unfriendly world, moving on to the land of promise.” (Ironside, 1984, p 10)
Peter’s great theme is the base of the hope of believers; the cross and resurrection of the Lord Jesus Christ. His letter is a challenge to imitate Christ, to have a dynamic personal and living faith that stands under pressure, like a light house in the storm. “It was under the stress of persecution that the church entered into the fullness of her corporate life. The body of Christ learnt it’s unity in the school of suffering.” (Mastermann, 1912, p 28)
It is a strong call to hold the apostolic faith. With Jude Peter calls us all to hold the faith once delivered to the apostles and demonstrated in the church in Acts. The many parallels to Acts indicate Peter may have had an early copy of the book before him, and that would make sense, as Luke finishes this book while in Rome and the Roman Church would have copies of it.
Note these key doctrinal points that tie the early apostle’s writings together.
Evidence of human sinfulness, Acts 2:23, 3:14, 4:10. 5:30, cf 1 Peter 3:16.
The fore-ordained purpose of God, Acts 2:23, 4:28, cf 1 Peter 2;21, 3:17.
Fulfillment of prophecy, Acts 3:18, 24, 10:43, 1 Peter 1:10 12.
Resurrection and exultation, Acts 2:24, 31-36, 3:13,15, 4:10, 5:31, 10:40, cf 1 Peter 4:13, 14, 5:6, 10.
The means of redemption, Acts 2:38, 3:19, 26, 4:12, 5:31, cf 1 Peter 1:18, 19.
The stone rejected by the builders, Acts 4:11, cf 1 Peter 2:7.
No man is common or unclean, Acts 10:28, cf 1 Peter 2:17.
The Cross = tree, Acts 5:31, 10:39, cf 1 Peter 2:24.
Soul of the Lord was not left in Hades, Acts 2:24-32, cf 1 Peter 3 : 19.
Christ raised by the Father, Acts 2:32, 3:15, 4:10, cf 1 Peter 1:21.
God is no respecter of persons, Acts 10:35, cf 1 Peter 1:17.
This first letter of Peter also provides the definitive advice to all believers of all time as to how we conduct ourselves when the state turns on us and starts to persecute us. 1 Peter 2:13-17, with Romans 13:1-6, have become the “loccus classicus for Christian citizenship”. (Elderen in ZPEB, 1980, p725).
These passages remain our standard. We are to follow them not the views of political activists. This remains our challenge and will be a more powerful one as believers enter times of increasing persecution worldwide!
The second letter, “like all second letters is corrective. In the first letter we hear the voice of the teacher. As a rule in second letters, it is rather the voice of the prophet or exhorter who speaks.” (Ironside, 1984, p 64.) This is much more due to the fact that Peter is facing death, and is passing his “last words” to the churches. There are twice as many perfect tenses used in the second letter to the first – eternal consequences are far more in view in this last word from Peter. “The purpose of second Peter is to warn, encourage and instruct the churches to meet the new challenges that a latter age would thrust upon them”. (White in ZPEB, 1980, p 728). Peter knows there is limited time for him, and he gives maximum emphasis upon each believer getting clear the “eternal life perspective” on all matters they face.
PETER THE MAN
Peter was, even in the early days, the spokesman of the twelve. Matthew 15:15, 16:16,18:21, 19:27, Mark 8:29, 10:28, Luke 9:20, 12:41, 18:28. Others considered him the leader, for example, it was to him that the enquiry about the temple tax was made. Matthew 17:24. Even though James would take the lead later it is Peter who establishes the church in Jerusalem and is its key preacher throughout the early chapters of Acts. He retains his strongly Jewish perspective and practices the faith of his fathers, observing the times of prayer in the Temple, Acts 2:46, 3:1, and uses the Stoa of Solomon for his preaching as did other Rabbis. While some see this as a “limited view” (Van Elderen, ZPEB, p734), it is better seen as his correct observance of his traditions, and a necessary and appropriate thing, given he was called to preach to his fellow Jews.
Peter's early life as a believer is recorded in Acts and other New Testament letters. He is in Jerusalem first but sees Cornelius and later is a delegate from the first church to Antioch (Galatians 2:9-14). In Acts 16 Paul is forbidden by the Holy Spirit from entering the areas that Peter records as the recipient of his first letter.
Could it be that Paul was not allowed to go there because the Lord had Peter as the evangelist in mind to visit the area? We cannot know for sure, but it certainly seems logical. In 1 Corinthians 1:12, there is a Petrine party in the city, indicating that the Apostle Peter may have visited Corinth or at least locals had visited him somewhere. It is a church tradition that Peter reached Rome around the mid - 50s of the first century, and that he worked with the predominantly Jewish churches there until his death in the city.
Moffatt believes he was a survivor of the first persecution of Nero. He notes, “there seems no crucial objection, so far as internal evidence goes, to the acceptance of the homily as it stands, viz, as a pastoral letter sent by Peter from Rome during the seventh decade of the first century.” (Moffatt, 1963, p 87). I disagree, as tradition is very strong on this point and his grave/body’s discovery recently leads serious weight to his death and burial as a result of Nero’s persecution.
Ironside also believes Peter may have outlived Paul from the internal evidence of the second letter, which he notes, “has been accepted by the church since the second century at least, and by many reliable witnesses from the first.” (Ironside, 1984, p 64). “Paul was in all probability already with the Lord when Peter wrote, or else he was enduring his last imprisonment just prior to his martyrdom; for Peter mentions ‘all his epistles’ as being in circulation already.” (Ironside, 1984, p 63).
Dean Farrar follows the church tradition, and it tells a different story, although we must observe again that we do not know finally which is true. Farrar tells the story (he refers to it as a “legend”) as the church records it of Peter’s death. “On seeing his wife led to execution he rejoiced at her journey homewards and addressing her by name called to her in a voice full of cheerful encouragement, ‘Oh remember the Lord!’ He was executed on the same day as St Paul. They parted on the Ostian Way, and then Peter was led to the top of the Janiculum, where he was crucified, . .. ....at his own request head downwards because he held himself unworthy to die in the same manner as his Lord.” (Farrar, 1884, p114, also refer to Eusebius, Ecclesiastical History, II, 25, 5 - 8 for the earliest surviving account of this tradition).
THE RECIPIENTS OF THE FIRST (AND POSSIBLY THE SECOND) LETTER
This first letter was an Epistle that was, “the child of many tears and much sorrow” (Meyer, 1953, p9). It was written most likely from Rome, as we have seen above, although some speculate that Egypt was its place of origin! (noted in Kelly, 1969, p 237). Rome was commonly referred to as Babylon by the early church. (Mastermann, 1912, p 32 who records comments by Clement, and Lightfoot).
Jewish converts, possibly from the day of Pentecost, carried the gospel into the regions mentioned by Peter well before any specific missions were launched. Peter’s visit to the region may be dated by comparing Romans 15:19, 20, with Acts 16: 6, 7. “Because the Christian mission was already going forward in Bithynia and parts of Asia prosperously and peaceably, and it was undesirable that St Paul should build upon another man’s foundations. No great boldness would be involved in the surmise that this work was under the direction of St Peter himself or of St Peter and St John.” (Selwyn, 1952, p 45).
“Pilgrims, chapmen, and traders of all kinds, soldiers, subordinate officials, all played a part in the dissemination of the gospel, and there was probably no corner of the empire where Christianity had not been heard within a very few years.” (Bigg, 1956, p 72-73). When the order of the churches is looked at in terms of the Roman roads we may even have the route that the messenger took with the letter. “An excellent road ran from the Cilician Gates northwards through Cappadocia and Galatia to Amisus on the Euxine, probably the first city on that coast to receive the gospel”. (Selwyn, 1952, p 46).
Mastermann notes, “the order in which they are enumerated probably represents the itinerary of the bearer of the epistle who may be supposed to have landed in Sinope, . . . . . missionaries from the churches of Syria and Cilicia probably found their way into the Province at an early date.” (1912, p 15, 16).
The impact of the gospel on the provinces mentioned was significant for within fifty years when Pliny writes of the problems with the Christians in the area he reports to the Emperor Trajan that the temples are empty due to the spread of the gospel message. (Refer Ramsay, 1904, pp146ff) After Pliny’s short burst of executions, he is pleased to report that the temples are again full of probably very scared pagans, desperate to prove they are not Christians! We see similar things in Iran after a “crackdown” by religious leaders.
“Some synagogues probably went over to Christianity in a body, in other cases a part would secede and this part would exhibit a vertical section of the parent group from top to bottom”. (Bigg, 1956, p 71). The recipients were a mixed group, as it must be remembered that every synagogue had it’s Greek and local dialect speaking “god fearers”, as well as proselytes. (Refer to Selwyn , 1952, p 44).
“We have here distinct evidence of a bold and extensive mission larger in scale than any of the journeys of St Paul. . . . Silvanus is to visit them all, in person, or by deputy, and to send copies of the epistle everywhere. The object was to establish and confirm the churches, to bring them into touch, comfort them, and so pave the way for a further advance.” (Bigg, 1956, p 69).
THE LANGUAGE AND AUTHORSHIP OF FIRST PETER
Like all doctrinally powerful letters of the New Testament this book is attacked by the liberal critics (who always call themselves “the scholars”) but the evidence is not for them, it is against them. Tradition considered this first letter the letter of Peter from the beginning. As Guthrie notes, “the traditional view which accepts the claims of the epistle to be apostolic is more reasonable than any alternative hypothesis”. (Guthrie, 1962, p 114).
Eusebius records the doubts of some about the two letters, but both letters were accepted by the church fathers who were a lot closer to events than the nineteenth century German critics who reject these letters. “The actual arguments against the traditional authorship are not nearly as strong as has been made out”. (Cranfield, 1958, p 7). “The onus probandi rests with those who assail or suspect these books, rather than with those who accept them”. (Plummer, 1896, p 15).
The major attack centres on the Greek of this letter compared against the Greek of the second. Even Guthrie asks, “the question must be posed, whether the author of first Peter could have written second Peter and the verdict given by the majority is in the negative.” (Guthrie, 1962, p 148). If this is still so today 60 years later, what is the solution?
The Greek certainly is clearly different. “First Peter is beautiful Greek, second Peter is Greek as though the writer was looking up everything in a lexicon. First Peter is magnificent in the way it flows. Second Peter moves along awkwardly. How could they possibly be written by the same man? 1 Peter was almost certainly written through an amanuensis, 2 Peter was doubtless written by the apostle himself, who was unfamiliar with the language.” (Criswell, 1975, p 11).
Pause for a second here. Was Peter unfamiliar with the Greek language? A great deal is made of the statement in Acts 4:13, that Peter was an “unlettered fisherman”. “Such a letter could not have been written by him, the illiterate fisherman, if he had lived to be a hundred”. (Beare, 1947, p24). Even Guthrie expresses doubts about Peter’s Facility in the Greek language” (Guthrie, 1962, p 99). Reike is more foolishly blunt, “the unlettered Galilean fisherman Peter would hardly have been the master of this Greek style”. (Reike, 1964, p 70).
Galilee was however a bilingual area, and so Peter would have had to have elementary Koine Greek to trade in fish, but Reike ignores the historical reality that the entire area was bilingual (Greek and Aramaic used by most)! It is now thirty years since he has been a fisherman and he has certainly been moving in a Greek speaking world where he would have had lots of opportunity to learn the language far beyond a basic conversational level. The word “unlettered” in Acts 4:13, does not mean stupid or simple, it means not a university graduate! The liberals in their desperation to down grade Scripture downplay Peter’s intelligence and linguistic ability, and they have no warrant or real evidence to do so!
But where does the beautiful style of 1 Peter come from? Perhaps from his companion at the time, Silvanus, the scribe used by Paul also as an amanuensis (or writer who helps form the thoughts in the right words for the occasion). Beare refers to the amanuensis theory as, “a device of desperation” (Beare, 1947, p 183), but is it simply logical? Yes it is logical, and was normal for the day, and it fits the facts better than the liberal’s assaults on the truth without any warrant at all, except their “desperation” to avoid truth! They are the desperate ones. The use of the amanuensis was common at this time, and even Paul, a university graduate, uses Silas and thanks him publically.
Jerome, the early church father, felt there may have been two literary helpers that worked with Peter to write the first letter. This was a common practice in the ancient world, and would make sense for a man who was fluent in conversational Greek, and preaching, but getting the written form right would benefit from the assistance of a trained writer like the scribe Silvanus. Even today PhD graduates utilize several professional script editors for their books!
This man had worked with Paul on at least two of his letters and is likely the humble co-worker behind this first letter of Peter’s. “It is reasonable to attribute to him the refinement of Greek grammar and style and the literary vocab while, at the same time recognising in the letter the message, personality and apostolic authority of Peter”. (Cranfield, 1958, p 8).
The similarity of Peter’s language to his preaching in Acts has been noted by several commentators. Farrar notes, “the style of St Peter in this epistle resembles in many particulars the style of his recorded speeches. It is characterised by the fire and energy which we should expect to find in his form of expression.” (Farrar, 1882, p 123).
Peter knows the works of Paul well and quotes or alludes to a number of Paul’s letters. There are eleven references to Romans, ten to Ephesians, and 8 to James’ letter. Peter is not a simple quoter of others as Farrar notes, “the originality of St Peter is not only demonstrated by the sixty hapax legomena (only use of a word in the Greek New Testament) of his short letter, but also by his modification of many of St Paul’s thoughts in accordance with his own immediate spiritual gift.” (Farrar, 1882, p 132).
The form the letter takes gives rise to speculation as to its original purpose. It has an immediacy and power that indicates its source was likely a powerful sermon that has been recorded for the benefit of all the churches. Most believe it was written out as a baptismal sermon and circulated for use at baptisms, as it is appropriate to mark the start of a believers walk with the warnings about the trials that may await them.
Whatever the source of Peter’s material, an immediacy is apparent as we read his words in both letters, although the second will double the perfect tense usage over the first. Baptism is certainly in view in the First Letter and chapter 1:3 - chapter 4:11 may be the text of a message Peter gave for a baptismal service or at Easter time, but there are many commands and exhortations in this letter that indicate it has the wider church membership as it’s intended audience not just new believers at baptism.
Whatever formed the original message the letter takes this and strongly urges the young believer to take seriously the grace they have received and urges all to loving steadfastness in the midst of trial. Mastermann identifies a three-point sermon here; holding the hope of the inheritance, following the example of Christ, and the certainty of God’s justice. (Mastermann, 1912, p26). If this is indeed a baptismal sermon for distribution, Peter would want professional polishing to be done and that explains the amanuensis.
One of the interesting features is Peter’s humility throughout the letter. He “keeps himself well in the background and makes no parade of the apostolic status he assumes”. (Stibbs, 1959, p 31). Peter is always aware of his place to be obedient to every command he gives to us. Many who are leaders speak only of what others must do, they use the word “you” often, but for Peter it is the word “we/us” that is the important one. Look up the verses around the following. 1 Peter 1:3, 2:24, 3:18, 4:17. “Behind the ‘us’ of 1 Peter lies the authoritative witness of the original disciples”. (Selwyn, 1952, p 28). This remains our challenge – Christ like leadership! Matthew 20:25-28.
THE LANGUAGE AND AUTHORSHIP OF SECOND PETER
“No New Testament document had a longer or tougher struggle to win acceptance than second Peter”. Kelly, 1969, p 224). “It is the most problematic of all the New Testament Epistles because of the doubts regarding it’s authenticity and because internal evidence is considered by many to substantiate these doubts.” (Guthrie, 1962, p 137).
These two quotes are indicative of many comments about the second letter. How can we be sure about this letter? Is it genuine or is it a second century fake that should have never got into the Bible? For this latter question is raised by the liberal critics! At EBCWA we believe it is by Peter, and that it is Holy Scripture, but do we have a good case?
The style of the letter is certainly that of Peter. It is vivid and powerful, full of spiritual insights and practical throughout. Farrar notes, “it is so marked by unity and coherence, this remarkable little letter which the church could ill afford to lose, and which is full of impassioned warning and eloquent exhortation”. (Farrar, 1882, p 183).
There was a clear difference between the two letters that was recognised by the early fathers of the church. Jerome placed it in the Vulgate translation but noted the difference in style, character and content. Differences were noted but they were not considered to be “fatal differences” (Green, 1968, p 22). Some early fathers found it hard to accept but “none felt it to be spurious, in spite of the hesitancy which existed over it’s reception”. (Guthrie, 1962, p 142, also refer, Green, 1968, p 15).
The style was certainly different. Note the following comments by Greek scholars. “The Greek of Second Peter is grandiose, it is rather like baroque art, almost vulgar in it’s pretentionism and effusiveness. Pedantic words such as rhoizedon, and cumbersome phrases, such as hyperonka mataiotes phthengomenoi, abound.” (Green, 1968, p 16).
“It is highly coloured, effusive, and pompous. It slips readily into iambic rhythms, it’s choice of words is bookish and artificial and it’s constructions laboured.” (Kelly, 1969, p 236).
“There is a rugged tautology in the Greek of the second epistle very different from the smoothness of the first”. (Farrar, 1882, p 186). Even though Farrar was unsure as to who it’s author was, he noted that “no-one can read it without recognition of it’s power”. (IBID, p 218, 219). Like Farrar, Michael Green believes in the power of the letter and sees that the verbose style may be a form of Asiatic Greek that preferred that style. (Green, 1969, p 18).
These comments may be all correct, but it makes more sense to see Peter reaching for his lexicon or asking advice about words from those around him in the jail; this is, I believe, a letter that he wrote without the help of the Silvanus! It makes sense if it was written as his last words from jail before his execution.
It is attacked by the liberal critics, as one would expect, given the content! Remember this issue when you see a passage of Scripture attacked. What is it speaking of? Liberals do not like being nailed in their sin of unbelief, they hate prophetic words, and they despise any eternal references, and so they will attack the most powerful texts! This letter is so different from the spurious letters of the second century that it is clearly a work of the first century and we believe from Peter in jail as he awaits his execution! Note the words of the attackers of Peter’s authorship of this letter, for their words betray them.
“Here we find the words of a second century author who writes under the name of Peter, modestly employing the apostles name in order to discredit views which he felt certain were unapostolic, . . . The discrepancies of language and thought are too well marked to allow of both homilies coming from the same author”. (Moffatt, 1963, p 173-174).
“Undeniably the Epistle presents the apostle Peter as it’s author yet it is reasonable to suppose that a follower of Peter composed the writing in the name of this great man”. (Reike, 1964, p 143).
“The author certainly represents himself as the apostle, . . . recalling his presence at the transfiguration and his receipt of a private communication from the Lord about his immanent death 1 : 14.” (Kelly , 1969, p 235).
Bigg, 1956, p 79, calls him a “forger”. At least he is honest with his views!!! He goes on, Peter “ was a married, uneducated labourer. Such a man always bears the stamp of his class. The Gospels paint him as a man of slow understanding but strong convictions.” (IBID, p 54).
“Finally when the strongly Hellenistic language and imagery of second Peter are considered it becomes extremely difficult to ascribe this epistle to Peter, the Galilean fisherman”. ( Reike, 1964, p 143, 144).
What arrogance these men have! They have pigeon-holed Peter as a fisherman, and in their limited experience all fishermen are stupid, therefore Peter is unable to be bilingual or learn Greek over the thirty years that have passed since the Gospel days, even though he is clearly moving in a Greek speaking world 24x7! Their local travelling salesperson could be fairly fully bilingual in six months by staying in a country, and yet these arrogant men believe Peter couldn't be after 30 years!!!! The critics are the stupid ones!
What was the churches view of a work written by another man claiming it was by someone else? Even though there was some acceptance of a work written, as if it came from a great person, such works were always considered second class.
As Guthrie notes, “no advocate of a pseudonymous origin for 2 Peter has been able to give a wholly satisfactory account of the motive behind it.” (Guthrie, 1962, p 169. Also Green, 1968, p 30). “The early church was not unconcerned whether the letters were genuine or not, as is proved by the controversy over admittance into the canon. Nevertheless, the fact remains that our conventions about copyright were not those of the first century.” (Sidebottom, 1982, p 100). Pseudapigraphy (pretending to write in another's name) was frowned upon, even though “different standards of literary proprietorship prevailed in those days”. (Green, 1968, p 32).
The so called, “Acts of Paul and Thekla”, was dismissed as spurious by the church, and, “it was into a church exercising this sort of discrimination that we are asked to believe 2 Peter was surreptitiously inserted. I find it very hard to believe!” (Green, 1968, p 33).
The Old Testament quotations in 2 Peter are all from Isaiah, Psalms, and Proverbs, all of which are quoted in 1 Peter. This is a letter that appears very different from the second century fakes, it has power and purpose, and any differences can be explained by the difference of purpose to the first letter, and the situation from which it came.
These are, we believe, the last words of the apostle as he awaited death. Its power is the Holy Spirit’s as he moved upon Peter. As a Jewish writer he draws upon Jude’s work, who as his fellow Jewish apostle was both well known to him and who thought the same way. There is nothing sinister about the use of Jude. (Refer to Sidebottom, 1982, pp67-69, and Guthrie, 1962, pp147ff).
Peter was bilingual, as all Galileans had to be to work. He had a Jewish name Cephas, but was known by his Greek one, as was his brother Andrew, a telling fact that indicates he could converse freely in Greek. For a discussion of this refer to the following. Bulloch, 1981, p 7, p105, also Stibbs, 1959, p 24, 25, 67, and, Kelly, 1969, p 31.
A fragment of a scroll from cave seven at Qumran appears to quote 2 Peter 1:15. If this is proved it indicates that the letter was known in Jewish circles well before 135AD. White sums up the case for the letter to be Peters. “The early church showed more care and suspicion in regard to the authorship of 2 Peter than almost any other epistle. Although most of the doubts had ceased by the end of the fourth century, . . . the evidence supports the Petrine authorship.” (ZPEB, Vol 4, p 727).
With this certainty let us open these two letters and let the Holy Spirit bring them to life for us and strengthen us are they have strengthened all previous generations. As we are seeing from the prophetic updates, 2015-2022, all the signs of the Lord’s Return are now beyond obvious to all who look at the facts. We are indeed in the last days of the Church Age, and we need to be focused on these “last words” of the apostles, for they speak directly to us all and call us to action.

