Those who hate truth will try to discredit those who powerfully proclaim it. John powerfully preaches truth and strongly recalls the people to the full Spirit filled reality of their walk with their Lord. Satan hates this sort of message and so do all who do his work. The main attack upon the legitimacy of the letters centres round their history and then their linguistic structure and their vocabulary. Even in the attacks there are total contradictions between the attackers.
I will quote from a number of these people, not to waste your time, but so that, as a serious student of the Word of God, you can identify them quickly. You need to learn about your enemy by hearing their words, and so be able to spot their words when you hear them in the local church from any unbelieving minister. Satan has not had an original thought for a couple of thousand years, and so learning about how the enemy sounds helps protect you from future deception, as most attacks upon truth are repetitions of things that have occurred before. Satan’s people all sound the same!!!
One writer observes, “Nearly forty words used by the writer of the Epistle are not found in the Gospel, and there are also common words in the Gospel that failed to make the Epistle at all. The Gospel of John makes much use of the Old Testament, but the Epistle contains no quotation from the Old Testament at all, and perhaps only one reference.” *Note 1
Another attack upon the letters was to separate the three, claiming the first was authored by “a John”, but not necessarily the Apostle John, and that the other two were authored by another John. They do this by identifying his use of the term “elder” rather than Paul’s use of apostle, arguing that this makes it unlikely that it is John the apostle who is the author. We will examine this below (The Elder). The early church father Eusebius, writing in the early 300s noted that the authorship of 1 John was unquestioned in his day, but that some disputed the two smaller ones as being from the hand of the apostle, although most accepted them as John’s. *Note 2
One writer however observes, “The second and third letters of John naturally form a pair. The similarity between them is too close to admit of any explanation except common authorship or conscious imitation. It would take the ingenuity of the most skilful separator to determine which is the original and which the copy.” He then goes on to say, “A careful comparison of instances of words, phrases, and constructions which are common to the two smaller epistles and the larger epistle establish beyond the possibility of doubt the intimate connection between the two. A knowledge of the first epistle or its contents seems almost necessarily presupposed in some passages of the smaller epistles.” *Note 3.
As the believing Commentator Guthrie observes, “Johannine thought pervades the Epistle”. *Note 4. Those attacking the authorship have major difficulties. “If however we assume an imitator, we must confess that he has done his work with rare skill, and upon internal grounds therefore the hypothesis of fiction falls short of complete plausibility”. *Note 5. Note how polite these scholars are! They refute the attackers politely; something I do not believe John would do! We need to reflect as we read these observations on the words of the “Son of Thunder”, on those who would try to undermine his word’s authority and think about what his response would be.
The linguistic connections between the Gospel and the First Letter are extensive as the following observations make clear and the variance of a few words here and there reflect normal writing of all ages. “The style of the Epistle bears a close resemblance to that of the Gospel, both in vocabulary and style.” *Note 6. “The similarity is not confined to style and vocabulary, but extends to ideas, both as regards doctrine and ethics.” *Note 7. “No imitator of the Gospel could have combined elements of likeness and unlikeness in such a manner.” *Note 8.
Common authorship of the letters and the Gospel is indicated, especially when you look at three key points and words.
1. Logos: - John 1:1, 14, 1 John 1:1, 5:7, Revelation 1:2, 19:13.
2. “Have sin”: - John 9:41, 15:22, 24, 19:11, 1 John 1:8.
3. Paraclete/Comforter: - John 14:16, 26, 15:26, 16:7, 1 John 2:1.
*Note 9. These three words or concepts, plus many more possible examples, make it clear that the author of the three books is thinking and expressing himself the same way; it is the same man.
5. THE “ELDER”
Let us start with the observation of one commentator. “There is nothing in the use of the title ‘the elder’ by the writer of the epistle, that is inconsistent with the belief that he was the apostle John”. *Note 10. The very term “elder” had a specific usage in the early years of the church.
“The ‘elders’ was a general term for the first generation of the leaders of the church. John the apostle, last link between the Lord and the church in the closing decade of the century, was pre-eminently John the Elder”. *Note 11. The other use of the term ‘elder’, meaning old man, may also be appropriate here, for these words are indeed those of an old man; one who has lived long and reflected much upon what matters and what does not. The old man coming out of the severe treatment upon Patmos was getting ready to die, and at such a time in life self disappears and what we believe and who we worship becomes our only theme – that is the feel of John’s work. He has little time for self – it is all about the Lord!
“He was a theologian; the quiet master of the secrets of the spiritual life. He was the calm, strong controversialist who excludes error by constructing truth.” *Note 12. “When this epistle was written John was probably the only surviving apostle. The years had mellowed this disciple whom the Lord loved, the one who had leaned on Christ’s bosom. In this last inspired word to the church, the author retires to the background, unwilling to speak of himself.” *Note 13.
He speaks throughout the epistle, “with the authority of an apostle”, (*Note 14), yet he makes no clear claim to the title by using the word. Is this not consistent with one who was so well acknowledged in his day that he didn’t need to use the title at all? Comparison with Paul’s use of the term is often superficial. Paul used the title, as he was writing in the earliest days and uses the term to make clear that he claims authority to speak in the Lord’s name, but forty years later, John, now in his late eighties or early nineties, does not need to make such claims, for he is the last of that great band.
Some liberals are still determined to argue for the author being, “an elder”, but most do so with some attempt at least to indicate their own shaky ground. “Our tentative conclusion therefore is that the three Johannine Epistles were written in the province of Asia between AD 96 and 110, or thereabouts, by one of the Presbyters who are known to have lived in that province at that period. . . We are here, it must be repeated, in the realm of pure conjecture.” *Note 15. Most, even amongst the liberals, date the letters to between 85 – 110 AD, but we would identify them as between 80-96 AD.

