The position on these letter’s authenticity is starkly stated by one believing commentator. “John clearly professed to be the work of the same author (as 1 John) and we must choose between accepting this claim on the one hand, and on the other regarding the work as a deliberate fiction”. *Note 16.
Having stated the obvious point here, we must ask ourselves why anyone would forge such short letters? Speaking of 3 John, another believing commentator asks, “It is so brief and so unimportant in content, that we can well understand that there were few occasions for quoting it, but we could not understand why anyone should have taken the trouble to fabricate it”. *Note 17. As we will go through these letters, we will see that they do have some very vital things to teach us about attackers of the truth, and the biblical response to such people. They are important, and they have survived for a reason. Both letters are in a very standard letter format that remained fairly consistent for the Greek speaking half of the Roman Empire from the first through to the fourth centuries. These two short letters may have been written quite close to one another, and may even have been, “more of less contemporary responses to the same disturbance”. *Note 18.
The scholarly consensus on these letters is as follows. First, examine a grudging acknowledgement from a probable unbelieving commentator. “It is almost impossible to find any serious reason to explain their survival except the authority and reputation of their real author, whoever he may have been”. *Note 19. “On the whole, it cannot be said that the arguments for diversity of authorship are sufficient to overthrow the evidence, both internal and external, for common authorship”. *Note 20. “The consensus of scholarly opinion through the centuries has held to the common authorship for the fourth Gospel and the Epistles of John”. *Note 21. “On the whole, there are no conclusive external reasons for denying the authenticity of these epistles”. *Note 22. “The notes of similarity in these three epistles mean I find no problem in accepting the fact that John wrote all three”. *Note 23.
It is interesting to see that after nearly 200 years of consistent liberal theologian’s attacks upon the integrity and truth of the New Testament books that they have admitted defeat regarding these letters. Even when a commentator wants to undermine their authority he is forced to admit the truth over a number of pages. “The result of a half century of analysis has been to show that the Epistle cannot be explained in terms of written sources; we have to reckon rather with the utilization of tradition by it’s author. (page 30) . . . Common authorship of all three epistles remains the overwhelmingly probable hypothesis. (page 31) . . . Critics are generally agreed that the linguistic differences between the Gospel and the Epistles are certainly not adequate to bear the weight of proof of different authorship.” *Note 24.

